News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by nkingsy on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @09:41AM (#19614481)
The author draws a very unsubtle if not direct line between housing costs and homelessness. Is there any? I was under the impression that most of the homeless are mentally ill and/or transplants from other areas. What percent of them just can't afford the rent?
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by thrav on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @10:03AM (#19614696)
I had a coworker ask me if there’s any chance that losing everything you’ve ever held dear and being forced to live in such a scary environment might lead to some of what we perceive as mental illness. I think he’s onto something.

The effects of trauma are lasting and real and I’d imagine there’s a healthy amount of trauma being created in homeless encampments.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/talking-about-trauma...

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by chess93 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:20PM (#19616249)
Its not really "what we perceive as mental illness", it's just a mental illness. It doesn't have to have an innate biological component to be a mental illness.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by Symmetry on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @10:27AM (#19614995)
There are many sorts of homeless people. Many wouldn't be able to support themselves no matter how cheap housing is. There are many who wouldn't be homeless if housing was cheaper. This last group is the one typically targeted by laws against sleeping in cars at night. It's hard to give percentages, though.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by wonderwonder on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @10:24AM (#19614966)
40% of American's cannot afford a $400 emergency. For those without a family / friend support system something as simple as a car accident, hospital stay or losing their job could quickly lead to living on the street. I think the vulnerability of low income people is very underestimated for those who don't have a safety structure such as family etc.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by bluejekyll on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @09:52AM (#19614587)
This is a popular myth.

https://www.sftu.org/2018/06/five-myths-about-the-homeless-p...

According to that, 71% of people on the streets of SF used to be homed, and aren’t on the streets due to drugs.

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by rsync on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:33PM (#19616414)
This, and other statistics like it, are really disingenuous and framed for a very specific interpretation. Here is the actual quote from the article (strikethrough is in the original - not sure why - maybe a bad stat ?):

"The vast majority of the people who are homeless today used to be housed – in San Francisco. According to the city’s 2015 homeless count, 71 percent of the people on the streets were living in San Francisco when they lost their housing. That means seven out of ten homeless people used to be your neighbors – before the tech boom and the eviction epidemic. "

So the presentation here is that average-joe-normal-churchgoer was minding his own business as a lifelong SF resident and was then evicted by an evil landlord, so his apartment could go to a techie, which sent him into a downward spiral to homelessness.

I have not done independent research into this myself, but I have a suspicion that the actual narrative is something like:

"borderline mentally healthy individual moves to San Francisco because it's interesting and fun and romantic (and warm) and, while still on their meds, manages to rent a room or an SRO or something, lives there for a month or two or six, runs out of either money or meds or familial support (or all three) and suffers their financial/emotional/mental breakdown here, on our streets, far from any support or family they have, if they had any at all."

If this suspicion is correct, it doesn't imply we shouldn't be compassionate or helpful or progressive in our responses, but it does suggest that we are importing problems and should consider how we might limit that tendency.

It also does not place some kind of moralistic "maybe they shouldn't be doing drugs in the first place" judgement on people - at the end of the day it is indeed a mental health issue. Just maybe it doesn't need to be our mental health problem.

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by bluejekyll on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:03PM (#19616725)
yeah, not sure what happened with that link on their site. SF Gov seems to have moved the report. Here's a breakdown by St. Anthony's: https://www.stanthonysf.org/san-franciscos-2015-homeless-cou...

(to be clear this is from 2015, so nearing 4 years out of date)

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by rsync on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:25PM (#19616979)
Thank you for posting the actual link - that is helpful. From that link:

"Survey results show that 71% of respondents were living in San Francisco when they became homeless, and of those, 49% had been living in San Francisco for 10 years or more."

This sheds very little additional information. This statistic is often presented as if 71% of the homeless had their own apartment before they became homeless, but for all I know (and what I suspect) is that many of these people were "housed" in very tenuous, precarious situations that I might, personally, find indistinguishable from homelessness. We really need to know the specific definition of "housed" used in this survey.

That 49% of those 71% were physically present in SF for 10 years or more also tells us very little. I am led to believe that homelessness and the mental illness(es) that lead to it are cycles and that people fall in and out of ... the statistic, however, is presented as if individuals were happily housed in a plain old apartment for 10+ years before lightning struck and they were suddenly strung out on the street...

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by shalmanese on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:48PM (#19618285)
Seriously, get off the internet and go volunteer at St Anthony's for an hour. You'll get to meet some representative sample of the homeless in San Francisco and gain a much more high resolution picture on what all the various causes of homelessness are. The picture is complicated but it's not at all what you're positing.

I guarantee if you spend a week working with the homeless in San Francisco, you'll meet at least some people more intelligent than you, people who at one point earned more money than you, people who are more mentally composed and happy than you. You won't meet all of them in the same person but you'll meet at least one example of someone who can disprove every single simplistic pet theory about homelessness ever proposed.

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by rsync on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @04:46PM (#19618791)
You're talking past me to a prototypical "person who (you) disagree with". To wit:

- I made no comments about homeless people being uninteresting or unintelligent or how much money they do, or did earn, etc.

- I have presented no pet theories about the causes of homelessness or the demerits of the homeless.

I have simply pointed out that a very, very commonly published and cited statistic is, in my opinion, very ill defined and probably misused. I also suggested a possible alternative narrative that I suspect is more correct.

Please don't put all of the things you hate into a box and then shove me in there with it.

"Seriously, get off the internet and go volunteer at St Anthony's for an hour."

I have done that all over the world.

Cheers!

Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by shalmanese on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @09:47PM (#19620997)
If you suspect it's more correct, go out and verify it (hint: It's not).
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by masonic on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @06:37AM (#19623374)

  According to that, 71% of people on the streets of SF used to be homed
The data does not say that. It says that survey responses claim they used to be homed there; there was no verification done whatsoever. Of course vagrants are going to claim they belong there.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by bluGill on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @10:02AM (#19614695)
Great article, but their bias needs to be seen through.
Re:San Francisco’s Slow-Motion Suicide by scottlocklin on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:32PM (#19617058)
It happened to some friends of mine, who were normal mid-low tier middle aged tech workers and who actually were born in the area. They made a few bad choices and ended up on the streets in their 40s. One of them killed herself.

There seems to be lots of people as you say, but I'm sure if rent was cheap, that would help out a lot. I dunno if you've ever been to the SF Bay Area, but rent is REALLY high. The only reason I stayed as long as I did was I had rent control.

The problems listed by this guy are real: the nimbyism of property owners is insane, and the city bureaucracy (pretty much everywhere in the area -Berkeley was particularly lol) is completely bonkers. I'd also point out that civic groups that should help things, like various homeless advocates, generally seem to make things worse. At one point there was an actual $1000+/month subsidy which paid people to remain homeless. You'd lose it if you got housing! I'm pretty sure Newsom got rid of it (to much howling), but it really stuck with me.