News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s $9 engineering marvel no one wants (2017) by imtringued on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @06:25AM (#19613243)
It's 2019 and Bluetooth still has massive latency problems if you don't use Qualcomm's proprietary aptX LL extension. In theory it is possible to have a good wireless audio experience. Stock Bluetooth doesn't give you any of that and pretending so doesn't make the problem go away. Meanwhile almost any crappy Chinese $2 earphone won't suffer from this problem.

We've had 200ms (roundtrip!!!!) video live-streaming via WebRTC from one side of the globe to another for more than 3 years now but stock Bluetooth still cannot accomplish that same task within the same room. If all you're doing is listening to music on your phone you might not care. But audio latency during video games or even just learning vocabulary via Anki (which is basically the thing I use my phone for) is annoying as hell.

There is no clear upgrade path in which wireless is always better than wired. aptX LL is "adequate" but it's not the default. It often requires 50€ transceivers for specific devices like your switch console, desktop/laptop, etc. It's even less common than the headphone jack.

In comparison solid state storage is superior to CDs in almost every possible way. It's more compact, faster, less prone to scratches, can be rewritten and it is cheaper ($0.10 per GB for SSDs, $0.20 for a 700MB CD). There is no reason to still use CDs.

Meanwhile wireless (= stock Bluetooth), needs to be recharged (acceptable sacrifice), has worse quality, suffers from latency and there are multiple proprietary extensions that substantially improve the user experience but they are not guaranteed and even cost extra compared to regular wireless. The audio experience is not better in every case! There are enough substantial reasons to prefer wired headphones over wireless.

I'm not saying wireless can never be good. I'm saying that it's completely squandering it's huge potential but yet it keeps getting pushed down our throats before it's ready. But why on earth is it not ready? It's 2019. Why isn't "wired < wireless" true in every case?

There are no comments on this comment yet.