Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by michaelchisari on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:19PM
(#1959938)
Do we have a clear declaration that this content is illegal? I wasn't aware we did.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by potatolicious on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:52PM
(#1960086)
You're right. I've always been under the impression that dissemination of classified material is illegal as part of the Espionage Act.
But a quick jaunt over Wikipedia is inconclusive. It seems the legality of these leaks is a lot less cut and dry than I thought.
If only we had courts and judges to handle this sort of thing! The government could file a complaint, a team of legal experts could take a look at the evidence, Wikileaks could present materials and arguments in their defense, and a final decision could be made. If Wikileaks' content was ruled illegal, then this court could send Amazon a letter asking them to remove the content. Amazon could, of course, appeal. Once the appeals process was exhausted, then they could be compelled to remove the offending material. (Not all of it, of course; only the material that the court deems "illegal", whatever that means.)
The whole process could be open and transparent, and nobody would have any grounds to complain or yell "conspiracy!"
Oh yeah, but they're terrorists, so they don't deserve freedom. Much better to punish them in private, so nobody knows what is and is not illegal. Then when the government doesn't like you, they can take whatever action they want against you, with no oversight! That would be a much better system! Potatolicious, you could say.
Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by stonemetal on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @07:33PM
(#1960415)
They at least have copyright infringement, and could probably get a big enough fine to shut down wikileaks.
Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by jackvalentine on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @07:51PM
(#1960479)
US (federal) Government documents are not entitled to copyright protection within America.
Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by stonemetal on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @10:49PM
(#1960927)
That depends on how much of the data is strictly government property. If any of it is was written by contractors, etc. it may still have that avenue.
Re:Amazon no longer hosts wikileaks
by michaelchisari on Thursday December 02, 2010 @05:54PM
(#1964012)
Any work derived by government contract is also not covered by copyright.