Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by rudd on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:04PM
(#1959865)
Well, they can't really say so clearly exactly what they did. In an effort to stop people from gaming it, they keep their exact algorithm hidden. When people get around it, they tweak it further, in an endless cycle.
My guess is that their solution isn't actually based on customer's true opinions of the vendor, and thus the solution is cheatable. Hiding the solution is probably their best option at this point.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by rmc on Thursday December 02, 2010 @06:08AM
(#1961760)
they keep their exact algorithm hidden
They didn't keep the exact algorithm hidden, they kept the whole algorithm hidden. They didn't even describe it in general.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by ams6110 on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @07:24PM
(#1960388)
Maybe the details will appear on Wikileaks?
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by Andrew_Quentin on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:59PM
(#1960109)
The people who are trying to game google, know exactly what the solution from google is, or will find out within weeks. The ones left in the dark are the others, that is, the innocent, or the people who are not trying to cheat google, who equally, can not hold google to account.
Thus, their secrecy serves no purpose but to further their own interests.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by JoachimSchipper on Thursday December 02, 2010 @05:49AM
(#1961718)
The "cheaters" will probably have a clue at some point, but unless you are skirting the edge this is unlikely to have much effect on you.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by barmstrong on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:43PM
(#1959773)
Total guess, but I believe Google licenses Yelp's data. They may be using the Yelp ranking in place of sentiment analysis to reduce the weight of those links.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by andrenotgiant on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:01PM
(#1959856)
they just crawl yelp like any other site, yelp happens to use semantic markup (microformats) on its data.
Google does show special search snippets, and _used_ to show yelp review snippets on place pages, thanks to the microformats markup.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by mycroftiv on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @06:14PM
(#1960166)
I also do not understand the distinction between the unrevealed "algorithmic solution which detects merchants that provide a poor user experience" and the "sentiment analysis" approach that they say they rejected. I don't get how it is possible to algorithmically detect poor user experience without using sentiment analysis! Isn't negative sentiment more or less the same thing as a poor experience?
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by robryan on Thursday December 02, 2010 @03:05AM
(#1961453)
What I was thinking when I read it, although crawling reviews is another option, both are gameable though. Even a very good algorithm is still going to have the problem of planted reviews, I don't think we are at the stage where an algorithm can decide if a review is genuine.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by amichail on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:25PM
(#1959685)
Maybe there was no change? They just want to discourage people from doing something similar until they come up with a good solution?
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by barmstrong on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:40PM
(#1959761)
Doubtful - "lets release a fake announcement" type ideas I think would get shot down quickly at Google.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by tsbaron on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:32PM
(#1959723)
Google's "opinion" for better or worse is fact. Let's hope they figured out a way to differentiate between genuine bad reviews and those with underlying motives.
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by joe_the_user on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:41PM
(#1959764)
Even more, once you move to anything slightly controversial, an opinion can be genuine, meaning sincere, but still not valid for the person searching ("they sold me the movie I asked for but it had too much violence!").
Re:Google responds to NY Times article by improving its algo...
by CWuestefeld on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:46PM
(#1959784)
Yes, just as with voting on HN -- does that downvote mean it's an inane comment, or just that someone disagrees?
we developed an algorithmic solution which detects the merchant from the Times article along with hundreds of other merchants that, in our opinion, provide a extremely poor user experience
The explanations of what Google didn't do and why are informative, though.