News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas emissions, decarbonize. Parent comment

Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by smueller1234 on Sunday April 07, 2019 @02:26AM (#19595137)
Let me argue that there's at least one more design flaw: backup generators are generally not very reliable. So for any given plant, there's a comparatively high risk that they don't work when you need them. This risk is non trivial even when the generators are well taken care of (both maintenance and regular test runs) but it's very easy to skimp on the tests.

My knowledge is from another industry that relies heavily on backup generators.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by Gibbon1 on Sunday April 07, 2019 @03:26AM (#19595350)
Friend of mine has a high school friend that a maintenance engineer. He has contracts to maintain diesel back up generators for hospitals. And sometimes they don't start. It's very disconcerting when that happens.

The other design flaw is diesel or no they require cooling water during shutdown. What bothers me for instance is during the 1811–12 New Madrid earthquakes the Mississippi ran backwards for a while. During other earthquakes you see significant uplift. If the intakes run dry because the local hydrology suddenly changes you're just fucked.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by smueller1234 on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:23AM (#19603550)
To add to that: backup generators are also a logistical mess. Diesel doesn't last infinitely. Do in particular if you expect to run large generators to sustain significant load (like in big data centers, I don't know how significant the load is for the backup gens of a nuclear plant), the amount of diesel you get to store is impressive. Which in turn means that the logistics/tank life issues of the fuel get worse.

The physical&power infrastructure side of big data centers is really quite interesting, by the way. Not something we all get exposed to regularly but I can only encourage anyone who has a chance to learn about it to take that opportunity.

[ Parent | on HN ]