News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by pfdietz on Saturday April 06, 2019 @05:57PM (#19593266)
No. If renewables are cheap, then batteries and other storage will just serve to reduce the fraction of time renewables are not covering demand (why charge the batteries with nuclear if cheaper renewable power is available?) The smaller this fraction is, the worse nuclear does economically.
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by radicalbyte on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:08PM (#19593311)
What if you need twice as much electricity in the winter as in the summer? You're either going to need double the renewable capacity (4 x if you're solar-based) or some kind of super battery. Which doesn't exist yet.

The point for nuclear isn't just to cover demand curves; it's that to decarbonize the entire economy you need to both switch current electricity production to low-carbon sources and increase the capacity by 3-6x to cover all other energy requirements (including sucking carbon from the air to counter chemical processes we can't decarbonize).

Nuclear has to be part of the solution.

Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by pfdietz on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:12PM (#19593332)
Solar is headed toward as little as $0.01/kWh, an order of magnitude cheaper than high capacity factor nuclear. At that price, you cover seasonal shifts by some combination of overbuilding and curtailment in the summer, plus production of hydrogen. You burn the hydrogen in the winter in relatively cheap gas turbines (simply cycle turbines + generators are around $400/kW). This would be much cheaper than seasonal low capacity factor nuclear.

The other thing that will happen is that energy-intensive industry migrates to lower latitudes where there's less seasonality. Sorry, Europe.

I don't think nuclear advocates have gotten through their heads just how dire the situation is for nuclear energy. It is just not anywhere close to viable now, or even needed, and you do yourselves a disservice by concocting flawed arguments that let you think otherwise. Nuclear is going to survive only by large reductions in cost (and those costs are not due to some conspiracy of your political adversaries; they are due to the complexity and difficulty of the technology). Otherwise, it's going the way of vacuum tubes and magnetic bubble memory.

Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by acidburnNSA on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:36PM (#19593434)
Some non-trivial nuclear capacity is expected to make high-renewable deep-decarbonization scenarios significantly cheaper [1]. That hydrogen and battery storage stuff quickly adds numbers to the system cost. Solar alone with no storage doesn't work even a little (because of night time).

[1] http://energy.mit.edu/research/future-nuclear-energy-carbon-...

Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by loeg on Saturday April 06, 2019 @08:17PM (#19593888)
Renewables (and batteries) simply aren't that cheap. Even ignoring externalities like disposing of EOL solar panels.
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 07, 2019 @07:14AM (#19596108)
Not yet. But if you extrapolate out the cost of solar. using the historical experience curve, as it builds toward tens of TW of installed global capacity it could get there.
Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by loeg on Sunday April 07, 2019 @07:17PM (#19600595)
If you extrapolate this trend line far enough, does it reach zero? There's only so much future prediction you can accurately make from historical performance.

> as it builds toward tens of TW of installed global capacity it could get there

And that's kind of the other problem. How much land is that?

Per this perhaps dated 2013 report[0],

It takes "3.4 acres of solar panels to generate a gigawatt hour of electricity over a year." Unclear on if that's only in sunny desert locales like California/Nevada, or average over the US, or whatever.

Anyway, if my math isn't radically incorrect, that comes out to 114 kW of capacity on average, in whatever these test conditions were.

Just 10 TW of capacity would require, uh, 1.2e12 m², or 13k "survey townships" (US land units get weird), or 466k "sections" (weird US land unit that equals mi²) or 298 million acres.

For some comparison, California is 164k mi². Texas is 269k. You could (hypothetically) cover the entirety of California and Texas with solar panels (433 mi²) and you still would not reach 10 TW of average production.

Admittedly, your scope is global and these examples are US states. But it is still a ton of land. Perhaps efficiency has increased slightly since 2013, but by a factor of 2 or more? 10? And how much space will we need in landfills for EOL panels?

Global demand was about 22,100 TWh/yr in 2011 (random figure), so say it's doubled since then; we'd still need something like 233k mi² of these panels to supply the world, assuming perfect capture from season to season and overnight. That's most of Texas in (2013) solar panels...

[0]: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy13osti/56290.pdf

Re:Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 07, 2019 @09:11PM (#19601149)
There's plenty of land for tens of TW of global capacity. Remember, the Earth is constantly being struck by ~100,000 TW of sunlight.

And no, an experience curve never reaches zero. It's a power law in cumulative production.