News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:13PM (#1959104)
Half of these are just wrong. The other half are just irritating.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by Timothee on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:29PM (#1959192)
How so?

For example, how are these wrong or irritating?

"Ask a person to draw the screen from memory and only the most important things will be remembered"

"Users always come with feedback in the form of solutions, not problems. Try to understand root issues."

"Try it and look at the data for decisions. Don't be attached to your decision"

Is it irritating because you find these obvious? I could see that. But the same way I know I should exercise more, eat better and sleep more, while still not doing it, it's always good to hear/read good advice again and again.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:51PM (#1959279)
If you asked someone to draw the screen of say http://godaddy.com from memory, they'd likely mainly remember the lovely lady wearing a 'godaddy' t-shirt. Is that the most important thing?

What we remember is different to what we want if we need it. "important" isn't specific enough. Who is it important to? In what context?

Should we also ask a hacker to write down the keyboard short cuts from emacs they remember and get rid of the rest of them?

I'm not going to get into an argument, but hopefully you can see why I made the comment.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by avk on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:11PM (#1959638)
> If you asked someone to draw the screen of say http://godaddy.com from memory, they'd likely mainly remember the lovely lady wearing a 'godaddy' t-shirt. Is that the most important thing?

That's exactly the point. Isn't that something the GoDaddy designer(s) should know and take into account? They want people buying domain names, not drooling.

Again with GoDaddy, do you want a sexy brand image, a lead gen wet dream, people to quickly buy domain names in bulk, etc.? I completely agree that "important" isn't specific enough but it's up to you, as the designer, to figure out the balance.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by mikegreenberg on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:22PM (#1959158)
Please oh please tell us which is which!! (And be sure that your answer is just as obtuse as your reply above! THX!)
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:30PM (#1959197)
I speak my mind shrug. I think it's better to say what you think than say nothing at all.

Either you love 'nuggets' of "wisdom" like this, or you hate them.

It might have also been the [tweet] spam buttons that got on my nerves (Makes you tweet out the 'nugget' with a bitly link back to the page).

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by mikegreenberg on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @03:16PM (#1959371)
Opinions are fantastic. The problem here is that your opinions are meaningless unless you support them. And whether you choose to back up your opinion or not in a meaningful way is the difference between reading/commenting on news _here_ versus reading/commenting on news _most_ other places.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by Jabbles on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @03:47PM (#1959525)
The problem here is that your opinions are meaningless unless you support them.

I think that was axod's main problem with the article.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by mikegreenberg on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:27PM (#1959701)
That may be, but how should I know that? Until the singularity occurs, the best of intentions aren't an appropriate substitution for even the weakest attempt.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by run4yourlives on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:07PM (#1959615)
I think 37Signals has done enough to support their particular opinions though, whereas I'm not sure you can say the same for axod, but I will stand corrected.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @06:36PM (#1960232)
I'm not the one charging $1000 per seat for my wisdom ;)
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by run4yourlives on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @08:40PM (#1960609)
Sales Lesson #1 - Value is determined by the purchaser.

See: $300 purses, $250 running shoes, $1500 Business class tickets.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by d2viant on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:18PM (#1959132)
Would you be more specific?
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:24PM (#1959166)
For example:

"Never go with your first instincts."

  Google "Always go with your first instincts" = About 50,800 results.
  Google "Never go with your first instincts" = About 7 results.
Both of those are clearly stupid advice to give. But if I had to choose one, I'd go with "Always go with your first instincts" based on my own anecdotal evidence.

It's just 37signals being contrarian, pretty much their MO.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by jasonfried on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:33PM (#1959211)
Out of context that one can be misleading.

The context was that our first instinct in a specific situation was to solve a much bigger problem than we needed to. Had we followed that instinct we'd have gone down the wrong road. What was better was to challenge that initial instinct and ask "What's the real problem here? How can we solve the most important part of that real problem as quickly and simply as possible? Maybe that'll be all we need to do." It turned out that was exactly what we needed to do.

First instincts often see big huge pictures. We've found that challenging that initial instinct helps us find the little piece of the big pie that is really in need of a solution.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by axod on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:39PM (#1959240)
I think TBH that's my main problem with these. They're all out of context, and so fairly useless without the back story.
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by noahkagan on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:22PM (#1959157)
It's less about them being right or wrong and more about the way they choose to run their business. It works for them, may not work for everyone.

For me the most valuable thing was really writing out the story of the site & simple mocks before you start building.

Trying to do more of that now.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by clyfe on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:21PM (#1959153)
They built a solid business on these principles...
Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by apl on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:45PM (#1959261)
I suspect it's the opposite. They built a solid, not spectacular business on clever marketing and craftsmanship. Then they extracted witty aphorisms from it, and became heroes.

It's a bunch of platitudes. Nothing straightforwardly false, but in such high doses? Smug and vacuous.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by swombat on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @02:44PM (#1959259)
No, they built a solid business on the experience and deep understanding that eventually led to these one-liners.

The one-liners are useless. The experience that led to them (which was, no doubt, shared at the "masterclass") is priceless.

Re:Business Lessons from 37 Signals $1000 Master Class by avk on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @04:25PM (#1959687)
Exactly, thus my comment above about attendees paying $1,000 for a learning experience: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1959654