> Your barber/chef cannot bullshit you, but your economist/software engineer can.
I strongly disagree. Nearly all of the serious misunderstandings of the world I have harbored in the past I believed because I trusted the words of key individuals I held in high regard.
Your reference to r/insanepeoplefacebook actually demonstrates that many people are able to recognize false information online.
Eh, so if you get a dinner that taste like shit or a haircut that looks lumpy and terrible you can't tell?
Held in high regard isn't the point, it's that you know what bad food tastes like. It's nearly impossible to tell whether an economist on television making market predictions has done due diligence or is just talking out of his ass.
Perhaps I misunderstood your comparison. I thought your comment was saying that interpersonal interactions in general (like a conversation with your barber) don't spread BS as well as internet apps. It seems like you were referring to the barber's ability to convince you that his skills are up to par?
The secondary point is when you divorce these pieces of information from their culture they become something else.
> Do we really think that people with lesser access to technology have better understanding of the world than those that have no internet access?
This seems related to what Nassim Taleb would say, "It's easier to macro bullshit than to micro bullshit." IE. Your barber/chef cannot bullshit you, but your economist/software engineer can. Over time the good information gets processed via something like natural selection and you end up with good ideas persisting. So it's not clear to me that a society with the level of information and no clear anchors is full of more understanding than those in the past. See: Lindy Effect
It's a very convincing argument. See Twitter, Facebook (/r/insancepeoplefacebook) et all.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect