Let’s consider five reasons why you should occasionally treat yourself to a cup of Joe.
It's arguing against the people saying "Your daily coffee habit is costing you a million dollars!" It's saying that is nonsense.
That isn't the same thing as issuing the opposite edict that you, yes you, need to rush out and drink coffee every. single. day.
Defending your right to make such purchases as you see fit isn't actually the same thing as insisting you spend $5 a day on coffee.
But I imagine this comment will fall on deaf ears. Like the time someone asked how to foster independence in their toddler and I told the story about locking up the breakables when my toddler began hurling his dishes into the kitchen sink like it was a basketball hoop so as to let him do his thing without it going bad places.
The eager young parent replied "I like that! I'm going to promptly start making my toddler put their dishes in the sink!!!!"
(facepalm)
Hopefully nobody is saying that. A $5 daily habit costs $20-30k per decade, after you factor in reasonably anticipated investment gains. No more no less. Viewpoints about what an ideal world would look like, or one's right to make such purchases, or whatever else, have zero impact on the cost. It is what it is. Each person has to make their own judgment about whether that cost makes sense for them.
So 5 coffees a week is ~2.7% of a full time wage. That is huge, anyone arguing otherwise isn't all over how percentages work. Only something like 10-15% of your average weekly wage needs to be saved to have a comfortable retirement. Reducing consumption is a double-whammy, you spend less on lifestyle so you need to save less to maintain that lifestyle. $5/day is a huge expense from that perspective.
I don't know how prevalent stupid decisions like a daily coffee are for poor people, but the costs are so high I expect not many of them do it. Having a stranger prepare your food and drink is a luxury for the wealthy.
It’s a cliché that refuses to die: personal finance guru Suzy Orman warned investors last week that if you “waste money on coffee, it’s like ‘peeing $1 million down the drain.’”
That's apparently the reason the article was written -- to rebut that claim in specific.
Most people who say to skip the $5 a day latte understand that that alone isn't going to make you rich. Instead, the point is to engage in good spending habits, the sum of which will make you at least substantially wealthier than you would be otherwise. The fact that Suze took it literally does not mean the advice needs dismantling. Quite the opposite.
That being said, I do think it's kind of interesting that this guy is writing about don't buy a latte. Buy as many lattes as you want, as long as you don't hire his firm. They'll hit you up for 1% of your AUM under $2M, which is going to hurt a lot more than lattes for anybody who still gives any thought to the price of one.
The article fails because it uses terminology to positively frame it as a treat while using terminology to include the negative framing when describing what you can do... it is terribly written.
The beater is often just as poor an investment due to the money you'll have to throw into it like a black hole whenever it fails. There's also the stress and instability it creates knowing it may not start the next morning.
If I put a lot more miles in it then I would be more concerned with break downs as it aged.
That is EXACTLY what the article is advocating, very explicitly.
Your case sounds very different than the "$5 latte a day habit", which is probably just someone standing in line in the morning, grabbing their coffee and absent-mindedly sipping it as they walk to the office.
You got an hour of shelter and a comfortable place to sit in a nice environment, plus power and wifi, in addition to the caffeine and enjoyment of a nice beverage. It sounds like you made an efficient use of the limited resources you had available to you.
And I think the $5 latte is meant to be a symbol of how to get your expenses under control, not a complete retirement plan. Add to cutting out the lattes cooking more meals at home, cutting your cable bill to the most basic Internet only plan, looking for a cheaper cell phone bill, buy a beater instead of a new car next time you need to purchase one...
Once you have your emergency fund, most debts payed off, and are starting to save a reasonable amount for retirement, then the $5 lattes maybe aren't going to kill you, as long as you keep your overall spending within your means.