Re:Errors – Gotta Catch 'Em All
by Faark on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:30PM
(#19585617)
> Disagree, in my favorite language you just add "?" to the possibly-erroring function et voilá, error propagated
And one of the first things I had to learn in rust was how make this happen with different error types. After that it was pretty much the same as exceptions. What functions return errors is a little more obvious, at the cost of extra boiler plate (most stuff being Result<...> anyway)
Checked exceptions Java style could be a perfect balance with just a few modifications. Compiler/IDE should mostly know whats thrown where, so specifying it manually should rarely be necessary. And still could visualize what can fail and with what errors.
And one of the first things I had to learn in rust was how make this happen with different error types. After that it was pretty much the same as exceptions. What functions return errors is a little more obvious, at the cost of extra boiler plate (most stuff being Result<...> anyway)
Checked exceptions Java style could be a perfect balance with just a few modifications. Compiler/IDE should mostly know whats thrown where, so specifying it manually should rarely be necessary. And still could visualize what can fail and with what errors.