what will be interesting is, say there's a genuine market rout (e.g. what happened with Lehmans), which should depress stocks definitely in the sector, but also in the wider market.
If all the money from the passively managed funds just stays put, will the stocks basically not take much of a hit?
Of course if it gets bad enough for companies to go broke, that could go wrong for the passively managed crowd as they'll stay in there till the end, most likely.
The stocks will still take a hit, as we saw in the case of 2008 almost everyone loses money in a market-wide drop. Many active traders went bankrupt as well, the S&P500 lost 50% of its value but didn't go to 0.
> Of course if it gets bad enough for companies to go broke, that could go wrong for the passively managed crowd as they'll stay in there till the end, most likely.
It depends on how quickly the drop happens. S&P500 index funds will sell stocks as they exit the top 500 (this is a simplification of the actual mechanism), so if the drop is gradual then it's not so bad. If the drop is sudden then there is a bigger problem, but the sudden drop is a problem for everyone, active or passive unless you're doing HFT.
One example of this "stock markets not reacting to external events" that seems to fit the trend is, to me , the robustness of the FTSE100 since the Brexit vote.
It's clear that companies are taking a financial hit in several places and will continue to do so (perhaps precipitously if it ends in no deal) however the FTSE100 is current around 1000 points higher than it was a year ago.
That could be because a large percentage of the funds in those stocks are passively managed and therefore don't react particularly to those external events.
Luckily I was able to find an excellent resource that dives into the exact questions we're discussing: https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1803j.htm
It also makes a note that a lot of active investors allocate funds into a weighted index basket to better match index returns, so it could be that both active and passive funds are contributing to the same price insensitivity.
As a final supplemental to the paper given above I also looked at the PE ratio of the S&P500 per year: https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio/table/by-year
One thing I would also expect is that as passive investing becomes a larger and larger part of the market we should also see the PE ratio rise.
I found a site that gives the PE by year (https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio/table/by-year) and calculated the following (2019 estimates removed).
For all the years 1871 to present: AVG. 15.7 Median. 14.775 STD Dev. 7.25
For 1980 to present: AVG. 20.72 Median. 18.15 STD Dev. 11.18
PE ratio for 2018 was 24.97, which is very high for all of history but seems reasonable for 1980 to today.
Thought experiment: If everyone put money into an index fund that guarantees returns, what is the difference between that and a Ponzi scheme?
No index fund guarantees returns, so the question is a non-sequitur.
With regard to the question of how does the fund keep value -- the fund holds the equities that are in the index. The equity prices rise and fall with the market, which is hopefully based on the fundamental discounted future value of all cash flows from the company.
Index funds don't have gains because people keep believing the price will increase. They have them because the market as a whole gains in the long run. Index funds lose value during market downturns.
Anyhow, no index fund offers guaranteed returns. These days I only see that from crypto ponzis.
How do you identify an active fund manager that will outperform the market over a long time period?
Do they still outperform the market when you also price in their fees?