Re:Ask HN: Is Forex Trading Gambling?
by notahacker on Thursday April 04, 2019 @10:19AM
(#19572582)
Yes.
It's zero sum, you don't have any real influence on the market if you're at the "give it a trial" level, and you don't have any knowledge advantage over other actors in the market. (cf. investing in stock categories you understand, which has the risk of losing money and significantly overestimating your ability associated with gambling, but does at least have a realistic prospect of an overall upward trend in prices and some possibility you can understand certain relevant things better than the big institutional investors moving the market price)
There are practical reasons to trade forex like a multinational company hedging against currency movements causing income to fall in one part of the world, but that doesn't sound like what your brother is doing...
It's zero sum, you don't have any real influence on the market if you're at the "give it a trial" level, and you don't have any knowledge advantage over other actors in the market. (cf. investing in stock categories you understand, which has the risk of losing money and significantly overestimating your ability associated with gambling, but does at least have a realistic prospect of an overall upward trend in prices and some possibility you can understand certain relevant things better than the big institutional investors moving the market price)
There are practical reasons to trade forex like a multinational company hedging against currency movements causing income to fall in one part of the world, but that doesn't sound like what your brother is doing...