Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart
by pdonis on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:32AM
(#19569327)
> what should I conclude about our ethics board from that?
That you should not believe you know the "right" answer to any ethical question.
> I don't think I'm undermining the anybody's dignity by claiming that the board should focus on more salient issues than how much dignity to grant various gender/sexual minorities.
Thinking that that question is not "salient" is the same mistake--you think it isn't salient because you think you already know the right answer. But what if you don't? You're not even considering that possibility, and that, I think, is a fatal mistake for an ethics board.
> We is you and me, on today, 2019, benefiting from the moral failures of those that precede us.
You're assuming you know which past beliefs were moral failures and which weren't. An ethics board shouldn't assume that.
> Those that follow us will no doubt benefit from our moral failures.
You're assuming you know that those particular things you cited aren't moral failures. An ethics board shouldn't assume that.
> I also haven't presented any of my particular ethical beliefs
Sure you have. You've made claims that you know certain things are wrong. Every such claim is an ethical belief.
> I've only presented ethical claims that I think all sound ethical systems uphold.
And your claim that "all sound ethical systems" uphold these beliefs is an ethical belief of yours.
That you should not believe you know the "right" answer to any ethical question.
> I don't think I'm undermining the anybody's dignity by claiming that the board should focus on more salient issues than how much dignity to grant various gender/sexual minorities.
Thinking that that question is not "salient" is the same mistake--you think it isn't salient because you think you already know the right answer. But what if you don't? You're not even considering that possibility, and that, I think, is a fatal mistake for an ethics board.
> We is you and me, on today, 2019, benefiting from the moral failures of those that precede us.
You're assuming you know which past beliefs were moral failures and which weren't. An ethics board shouldn't assume that.
> Those that follow us will no doubt benefit from our moral failures.
You're assuming you know that those particular things you cited aren't moral failures. An ethics board shouldn't assume that.
> I also haven't presented any of my particular ethical beliefs
Sure you have. You've made claims that you know certain things are wrong. Every such claim is an ethical belief.
> I've only presented ethical claims that I think all sound ethical systems uphold.
And your claim that "all sound ethical systems" uphold these beliefs is an ethical belief of yours.