News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by Ar-Curunir on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:38PM (#19568909)
Don't downplay the issue. It's not that she's conservative; I'm sure Google's executive groups are full of relatively conservative people.

No, the problem with her is that she's a transphobe and racist.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday April 04, 2019 @06:27AM (#19570684)
I've never heard of Kay Coles James before but going from what is in the article, she is expressing a concern that legally recognising the gender of trans women (but not trans men?) risks disenfranchising non-trans women further.

This is an existing concern of many, that must be discussed. I disagree strongly that recognition of trans women takes away something from other womens' rights (if nothing else because there are so few trans women), but the opinion seems to be widespread enough that it must be confronted, and by that I don't mean with knee-jerk reactions and twitter flamewars. Like, really debated. So that it can be put to rest and we can all move on to more productive debates.

But, calling someone who expresses that view a transphobe and a racist is not debating them.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by ummonk on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:03AM (#19570166)
Terms like "transphobe" and "racist" get thrown around so liberally that I've stopped caring if someone gets labelled that.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by Bendingo on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:23AM (#19569542)
> transphobe and racist

These attributes are neither objective not illegal.

Google are hypocrites; they want diversity, but not diversity of thought.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by sytelus on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:29AM (#19569570)
Not everything immoral has to be illegal. Good people draw line at former, not later.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:44AM (#19569626)
And morality is very subjective, thin line.

E.g. is it moral for male-to-female trans to compete in women sports events?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by adjkant on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:01AM (#19569692)
Instead of focusing on that, how about focusing on issues that affect the lives of most trans people, not a subset so small to be statistically insignificant by any measure, not to mention the near nonexistant impact that has on anyone else?

Why play on the thin lines instead of focusing on the issues that have the largest and broadest effects on people?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by tsukurimashou on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:30AM (#19570041)
>not a subset so small to be statistically insignificant by any measure

do you think the number of trans people compared to the world population isn't "a subset so small to be statistically insignificant by any measure"?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by tremon on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:35AM (#19570501)
Yes, I think it isn't. Here[0] is a meta-study that illustrates the prevalence of transgenderism across continents and across time. It seems that as the concept of transgenderism becomes normalized, its prevalence increases. This is the same effect we have seen with homosexuality, so it's not terribly surprising.

The short summary: as a lower bound, probably more than 1 in 10k people (0.01%) would identify as transgender. Including the DSM definition of gender dysphoria as an indicator, that figure rises to 1% or possibly even higher.

Now, my question to you: how small should a subset be to be statistically insignificant? For popular reference (and I apologize for using this example again), keep in mind that the global prevalence of Judaism is 0.2%.

[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20141205022609/http://web.hku.hk...

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:13AM (#19570887)
.. and Judaism is not interesting at all for majority of people. Only where Jews have or had major presence it's an interesting topic. Go ask Chinese or Indians or Japanese what they think about Jews.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by adjkant on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:42PM (#19575720)
No, I think those competing in sports and the resulting effects on the lives of others is not significant to merit a large debate on the issue. A vast majority of transgender people will not participate in high competition level sports.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by Bendingo on Thursday April 04, 2019 @09:04PM (#19578681)
> vast majority of transgender people will not participate in high competition level sports

I agree. However those that do will affect (negatively) all the non-transgender women they are competing (and winning) against. And that does have "the largest and broadest effects on people" just not only transgender people.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by adjkant on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:47AM (#19579782)
So how big is that compared to the life threatening issues facing trans people daily, and which do you focus your time on? To me, when people choose to spend time on this argument, it's indicative of priorities and how they value the lives of others, and whose lives. And yes, in an ideal world it's both. That's not the reality we have though.

I'd also generally challenge that one competitor in a field has that large of an effect on people's lives. Yeah, that first to second stings slightly. How about that 15th to 16th? And how many sports really have this problem right now? Let's again focus on this relative to its effects.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:02AM (#19570161)
It certainly does have a broad effect on people. It will certainly hurt girls who dream of succeeding in sports. Because, well, if you weren't born a man, you're in for a rough ride. That definitely touches much more people than few genuine transgenders who just want to compete on fair playing field.

Same issue how we treat transgenders touches a lot of other fields. E.g. who can perform body search? Can ex-male-now-female do body search on a female? I could easily see many females not so happy about it.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by tree_of_item on Thursday April 04, 2019 @08:56AM (#19571665)
Sport is a huge issue that affects a large number of people. You cannot just brush it aside like that.

The same reasoning is going to apply to e.g. restroom usage as well.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by w1nst0nsm1th on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:47AM (#19573688)
Indeed. It seems restroom discussion is a really important topic for american conservative people. But strangelly not so much locker room talks...
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by throwawaysea on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:46AM (#19569852)
Given that there is a constant push to control Google by activists on the far-left side of the political spectrum, I don't know how Google can be trusted with the control over information that it has today. Their often purposely-visible love for diversity is truly skin-deep, and I think Google being split up is the only way to reduce the risk that a small group of activists filter the Internet for the whole world per their own worldviews alone.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:00AM (#19569460)
Lots of even non-conservative people don't accept trans movement. It's quite a high bar if only trans-ok people are considered sane enough to participate in ethics board.

E.g. I'm 100% against trans participating in sports. It's disgusting when men pretend to be women just to have a record on their name. It's even more disgusting when it's celebrated as diversity or progressive or whatever.

Does that make me just a "relatively conservative" or full-on "transphobe"?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by adjkant on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:28AM (#19569564)
To break this down a bit instead of only downvoting:

> I'm 100% against trans participating in sports

There's a nuanced argument to be made here.

> It's disgusting when men pretend to be women just to have a record on their name.

This is not that nuanced argument. I can assure you no one that is trans "pretends" to be a woman for sports records. That comment (as well as the word choice of "disgusting") shows a severe lack of understanding of trans people.

> It's even more disgusting when it's celebrated as diversity or progressive or whatever.

This shows a particular bias against "progressive/diversity" ideas and colors the comments before them with an even worse light that highlights the lack of understanding.

> Does that make me just a "relatively conservative" or full-on "transphobe"?

Just like anything, there are gradients and being transphobic now doesn't mean you have to be in the future.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by tree_of_item on Thursday April 04, 2019 @09:00AM (#19571715)
> This is not that nuanced argument. I can assure you no one that is trans "pretends" to be a woman for sports records. That comment (as well as the word choice of "disgusting") shows a severe lack of understanding of trans people.

They may not view their own activity as "pretending" to be women, but the position of people like Kay Cole James (and many others, on both the left and right) is that they are simply not women. Whether or not they believe it about themselves is irrelevant.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:36AM (#19569594)
> This is not that nuanced argument. I can assure you no one that is trans "pretends" to be a woman for sports records. That comment (as well as the word choice of "disgusting") shows a severe lack of understanding of trans people.

I understand biology that born-male will be stronger in many sports than born-female even after a lot of hormone therapy (or maybe vice-versa in some sports). Born-female taking male hormones will have advantage over regular female as well in many cases.

You got gender disphoria and need a treatment for it? Sure. But there're side effects. Just like for many treatments.

> This shows a particular bias against "progressive/diversity" ideas and colors the comments before them with an even worse light that highlights the lack of understanding.

I'm considering ideas on their own merit, not how they're labeled. And it's disgusting that progressive/diversity label was ruined buy affairs like that. And yes, I definitely have bias against ideas that seem to have a label they're not worth of.

> Just like anything, there are gradients and being transphobic now doesn't mean you have to be in the future.

I hope definition of "transphobic" will change and I won't be called one in the future.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by adjkant on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:50AM (#19569649)
First, nothing you responded to clears up anything about your negative assumption that transgender people change for sports titles. That will always be transphobic and doesn't look at all into what the life of a trans person today or in the past has looked like.

But the body and hormone levels absolutely do affect physical sports, you're right. If you want to dig into hormones, what about intersex people? What about people classified as women with significantly higher testosterone levels? Despite the classification most hospitals do, a surprising amount of births show non-traditional genitalia, and if you go beyond the external looks then the waters only get murkier. How many athletes are actually not traditionally male or female but were simply never classified as such medically due to a lack of awareness and education? Do you then want to have all sports competitions separated based on hormone levels instead of sex/gender?

> I'm considering ideas on their own merit, not how they're labeled. And it's disgusting that progressive/diversity label was ruined by affairs like that. And yes, I definitely have bias against ideas that seem to have a label they're not worth of.

But you give no argument for the unworthiness of it and instead start from the assumption. Not only that, but you paint with a very broad brush and are not digging into any of the nuance. That doesn't scream openness and combined with other things you said again comes off as ignorance or lack of education on the subject.

> I hope definition of "transphobic" will change and I won't be called one in the future.

That definition will only go the other way as more people become educated on trans people. What defines transphobia is ignorance, not gusts of cultural wind. What would make your actions change will have to be you, not the classification of them.

As an aside generally, being transphobic or racist or sexist should not define you - it's a chance to learn and understand. It's not an identity, despite how it is assigned like one to many public figures these days. What's much more important than never saying or doing something sexist/racist/transphobic/etc is being open to changing and understanding to not do it in the future. Really it's just listening and understanding other people's experiences.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by JamesBarney on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:12AM (#19569728)
Just be clear I don't share any view points with the person you're debating but the Olympics does(or did) have a testosterone limit for certain female sports.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/olympics/2018/04/26/ne...

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:58AM (#19570146)
> First, nothing you responded to clears up anything about your negative assumption that transgender people change for sports titles

I don't care if they changed gender for the sake of winning sports titles or not. I'm against them competing in sports anyway.

> If you want to dig into hormones, what about intersex people? What about people classified as women with significantly higher testosterone levels?

That's definitely could an issue (see last paragraph). But IMO it's different that this is accidental from the individual's perspective. They themselves may be not aware of this. Sort of like getting lucky with good genes or rare mutation. Meanwhile for a transgender is purely a rational choice to transition. You may argue it's not fully rational since treatment is needed. But ultimately people do choose treatments and accept consequences for all sorts of illnesses.

> But you give no argument for the unworthiness of it and instead start from the assumption. Not only that, but you paint with a very broad brush and are not digging into any of the nuance.

Unfortunately interwebs comments are not well suited for a nuanced discussion. The person I originally replied to didn't go into nuance, neither did I. It'd be great if internet commentary moved towards more nuanced and longer discussions. But unfortunately old good forums with mile-long pagination are getting more and more scarce :( Especially with diverse audience.

> What defines transphobia is ignorance, not gusts of cultural wind. What would make your actions change will have to be you, not the classification of them.

I did research the topic and made my mind. IMO people who just jump on the ever-more-progressive bandwagon are much more ignorant. Ignorance shall be judge on refusing to look into the issue, not on coming to reasonable-yet-subjectively-wrong conclusions.

> That definition will only go the other way as more people become educated on trans people.

Personally I went the other way after reading more into it.

> What's much more important than ever saying or doing something sexist/racist/transphobic/etc is being open to changing and understanding to not do it in the future.

Yes. But that ability to change must be open both ways. IMO today's definitions went way too far and are too close to doing full horseshoe. Understanding is not just pushing the boundaries of what is progressive to no end.

> Do you then want to have all sports competitions separated based on hormone levels instead of sex/gender?

I'd support protection for the lesser (?) gender (women in endurance and power sports, men maybe in gymnastics?). Just have open group and the protected one for the lesser gender. In the long run, we'll probably need one more group for genetically-modified individuals.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by tremon on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:59AM (#19570586)
They themselves may be not aware of this. Sort of like getting lucky with good genes or rare mutation. Meanwhile for a transgender is purely a rational choice

This gets me curious. In your definition, a person with strongly deviating hormonal levels isn't transgender until they are aware of their situation?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:19AM (#19570907)
AFAIK modern transgender definition don't include hermaphrodites who were fixed in hospital right after birth.

Someone having issues with their hormones doesn't become transgender either.

So I'd say it's safe to say that the person has to have consciously chosen to transition to be considered a transgender. Also, people who didn't transition (yet) on hormonal level but did minor plastic surgeries and wear clothes accordingly are considered transgenders too.

If someone has XXY chromosomes and consider himself one gender their whole life, do they "trans" between something?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday April 04, 2019 @06:55AM (#19570812)
>> It's disgusting when men pretend to be women just to have a record on their name

When has that happened?

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:23AM (#19570917)
Google for trans ex-men competing as women and you'll get quite a few hits. Sure, nobody says that they transition just to win something. But having participated in amateur-ish sports, boy if some people don't take it too far to win even insignificant prizes using very dirty shortcuts. And some of those transitions do look fishy AF to say the least.

5sec googling: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/mar/21/transgender...

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:43PM (#19574368)
From your original comment I understood that your concern was with men pretending to be women to win in sports. Are you now saying that there is a problem with trans women competing in sports?

There is a difference between someone transitioning from one gender to the other and someone pretending to be a woman, for whatever reason.

The "5-second googling" example you give is a of a transgendered woman who is also an athlete. I don't see how this fits in with "men who pretend to be women to win".

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by vokep on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:28PM (#19574892)
What they're trying to get at is that a MtF trans person is still biologically male, no matter what, therefore has an unfair advantage and should not be considered to be on the same level as biological women.

The simple solution I think is that sports should be sex based, not gender based.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:27PM (#19578153)
I've been following Caster Semenya's case for a while. What you suggest is not a simple solution at all, I'm afraid. The issue of gender is much simpler- one just asks the person. The issue of sex seems to have become way too complicated in recent years.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:47PM (#19579520)
Hey, we could use the same for doping control! Just ask the person if they used any illegal performance enhancing drugs :)

What would stop me from lying that I am a woman (I could even put on some makeup) to compete as a women? In some sports difference between men and women is so big that average male athlete could easily compete with top-of-the-line females. There's more than enough incentive for some douchebag to go the dirty way to get some glory.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:15AM (#19580701)
>> Hey, we could use the same for doping control! Just ask the person if they used any illegal performance enhancing drugs :)

Gender is a subjective experience of a person. Doping is not. I don't find your comment funny.

>> What would stop me from lying that I am a woman (I could even put on some makeup) to compete as a women?

It wouldn't be enough to just "put on some makeup". The latest recommendation from the IOC for male-to-female transgendered athletes is that they must have testosterone levels in the female range for a year before they can be allowed to compete.

I struggle to believe that a male athlete would accept taking hormones or being castrated to reduce their testosterone so they can "pretend to be a woman" in order to compete. Not to mention, that would significantly reduce one's athletic prowess.

Generally, what you suggest is such a remote possibility as to be completely absurd.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Monday April 08, 2019 @02:23AM (#19602618)
> Gender is a subjective experience of a person. Doping is not. I don't find your comment funny.

Yet performance related to hormones is not a "subjective experience". Nor body composition. E.g. in cycling females are at big disadvantage because their hips are wider, making them less aerodynamic.

> I struggle to believe that a male athlete would accept taking hormones or being castrated to reduce their testosterone so they can "pretend to be a woman" in order to compete.

I see you haven't been in sports scene much. I saw even amateurs in local weekend-warrior league taking doping (the cheap one, with very clear risks later in life) just to win some meaningless local race. People fucking love even tiny slice of glory.

> Not to mention, that would significantly reduce one's athletic prowess.

Those people don't care about absolute prowess. They care about podium. For example, it's not uncommon for amateurs to cheat to qualify for lower-tier group just to singlehandedly win against weaker opponents.

Source: spent many years in local amateurs and semi-pros cycling scene.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:28PM (#19617020)
The suggestion that a man may pretend to be a woman to gain a competitive edge in sports remains arrant nonsense without any hope of redemption, no matter how you try to dress it.

What I don't understand is what all this has to do with transgendered athletes.

Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by webXL on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:14AM (#19569508)
No, you're just thinking aloud (and you earned some downvotes!) A word of advice: don't even respond to someone claiming a black woman is racist/"transphobe" just because she has conservative beliefs. There's no coming back for this person or anyone who thinks that is a sane comment.
Re:Google’s new AI ethics board is already falling apart by mantas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:25AM (#19569549)
Eh, precious internet points are not that important anyway.

I agree it's a waste of my time to respond to comments like that. But on the other hand, letting those comments dominate the public space unchallenged is just legitimising their views. Which leads to vocal minority getting even bigger and louder. At the end of the day, it's the most vocal people who set the playrules. And I'm not a fan of ever-more-progressive rules, CoCs and legislations.