If your point is "I want my cut in money", then you need to find someone who's willing to give you a cut in money.
> If I deny the use of my data (opt-out, right to be forgotten), I need a way to enforce that.
But that's easy to do: don't provide your data.
Your argument seems to be more like "bartering access for data should be illegal" or "it should be illegal to offer a free, ad-funded online service without offering the same service without any ads or tracking by the price that I want, a shrubbery, a nice one, not too expensive".
It isn't wrong, but it is a different argument.
PS: Sorry for the shrubbery joke, wasn't meant to ridicule anyone but myself :)
Phone company sells my location data.
My purchases are data minded.
"don't provide your data"
How would that work?
If someone's using my data, I want my cut.
If I deny the use of my data (opt-out, right to be forgotten), I need a way to enforce that.
Recognizing personal copyright to one's data is a convenient accounting (bookkeeping) method to implement privacy.
--
I'm not smart enough to follow OP Keith Axline's thesis. But it seems to me he has the cart before the horse.