News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by aylmao on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:49PM (#19565477)
I don't doubt regulation would help Facebook in some respects, but (in usual Bloomberg fashion) this article is also stretching some things a bit. For example:

> Start with harmful content, which Zuckerberg defines as “terrorist propaganda, hate speech and more.” Facebook would prefer that someone else decide what constitutes such content and should thus be taken down.

I agree with this. Having a private corporation that's invested in engagement, which is also headquartered in the US (very far geographically and culturally from some of the places it moderates) be in charge of defining what's right and what's wrong, is and has been a recipe for disaster— let alone the implications it could have around the sovereignty of nations.

> But it’s hard to see how this would benefit anyone but Facebook.

Excuse me, what?

> Inviting the government to arbitrate what qualifies as “harmful” speech is a legal and ethical minefield, while establishing a third-party system to do the same would amount to offloading corporate responsibility.

Isn't this the government's job though? To define what is a crime/wrong and what isn't, and to deal with the moral aspect of legal codes? Isn't this why we have laws? I don't think anyone is vouching for "big brother" type government control here, but governments always have a principal role in civil rights, inclusion and the moral development of a nation. It's part of their job, and the reason people care to have leaders with strong moral compasses as public servants. Has this view of government been lost in the US?

> There’s no reason to expect every platform to adhere to the same content policies, but every reason to want them to exercise judgment and accept accountability.

I'm there's things that should clearly be blocked or allowed. But the gray areas are what's being discussed here, and honestly I don't think that should be Facebook's job (or any private, American, for-profit corporation for that matter).

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by drngdds on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:14PM (#19565754)
It has never been the US government's job to decide which speech is 'harmful' and should be silenced. The First Amendment prevents that. (Of course, some things like slander are illegal, but that's nothing like the 'harmful speech' Facebook is talking about.)
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by reissbaker on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:21PM (#19566948)
It is entirely the US government's job to decide which speech is harmful: it just takes the view that most speech isn't harmful, and should be allowed. The First Amendment is part of the US government's decision on speech: its view is that most speech is more good than bad, and thus is protected. When it does decide that certain speech, like libel, is harmful, it bans it. It even can ban speech in specific contexts! For example, in Brandenburg v. Ohio the court upheld that speech "which would be directed to and likely to incite imminent lawless action" could be banned. So, saying an inflammatory thing privately to your friend, for example, could be fine, but boosting that post to millions of people could be viewed as "likely to incite imminent lawless action" such as a riot.
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by erichocean on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:12PM (#19567685)
> The First Amendment is part of the US government's decision on speech

This is just flat out incorrect.

The Bill of Rights was the people saying "You want a US government ruling over the several States? Here are the rules for what you're allowed to do." The US gov't never made a decision on speech, they agreed to the terms of "We, The People", full stop. You're acting like it's the opposite.

This is also why the gov't can't just rewrite the 1st amendment willy nilly—all of the US government's legitimacy with the American people comes from respecting the Bill of Rights. Stop respecting those rights and a rebellion is right around the corner.

Historically, the States had to approve the Bill of Rights (and the rest of the new Constitution) in order for it to come into effect. It's definitely NOT the US gov't "deciding", and it never was. All of the power resided in the States.

Interestingly, the "Federalists" that (re-)wrote the Constitution were mostly opposed to the Bill of Rights—that's the contribution made by the anti-Federalists to the US Gov't as it exists today.

Isn't it funny how most citizens treasure the Bill of Rights more than anything else in the Constitution? That makes it pretty clear which "side" had the well-being of the people in mind.

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by ben509 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:24PM (#19566390)
> Of course, some things like slander are illegal

Specifically, to prove slander, the defamed party has to demonstrate intent and damages. Same with fraud. Both of these are cases of "your right to swing your fist ends at the tip of my nose."

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by danieltillett on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:43PM (#19567114)
Not in many non-USA countries. Just damage and negligence is enough in many other English speaking countries [1].

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamation

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by ben509 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:04PM (#19567630)
It also depends if it's a tort or criminal.
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by duxup on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:57PM (#19565555)
I think there's a bit of a disconnect when it comes to "harmful" speech, and "illegal".

The US government isn't going to decide what is "harmful" at least not for long as a legal challenge would quickly do away with any such rules.

In the end the platforms have to decide for themselves and police themselves unless they want to be 4chan or whatever the next "post anything" kinda place is now a days. Right or wrong they're the only folks who can do it.

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by lorenzorhoades on Thursday April 04, 2019 @08:32PM (#19578520)
The only problem I see here is Facebook is offloading the 'hard problem' of algorithmically dealing with such massive data that requires top-notch machine learning algorithms to be able to detect sentiment at 'Facebook level Scale' to a massively more technically inept party. Look up how much money it cost to do the ObamaCare website, then tell the same party to develop an algorithm that Facebook, one of the biggest technology company's in the world, is having a hard time solving. This problem is only going to get harder and harder as the amount of data created is rising.
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by throwaway284721 on Friday April 05, 2019 @10:10AM (#19582635)
> I agree with this. Having a private corporation that's invested in engagement, which is also headquartered in the US (very far geographically and culturally from some of the places it moderates) be in charge of defining what's right and what's wrong, is and has been a recipe for disaster— let alone the implications it could have around the sovereignty of nations.

What? If Facebook decides it, it's a threat to sovereignity of countries other then the US, but if the USG decides it, it isn't?

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by smokeyj on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:10PM (#19566270)
> I don't think anyone is vouching for "big brother" type government control here, but governments always have a principal role in civil rights, inclusion and the moral development of a nation.

Lol, what does this even mean? You want a Theocracy with Zuck writing the scripture? Are your views tainted in any way by Facebook Incorporated?

The government and their role in defining "harmful" has been defined already. It's called the First Amendment. Might want to check it out.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_...

Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by dustindiamond on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:13PM (#19565744)
Who’s government?
Re:Zuckerberg’s Rules Would Hurt Everyone but Facebook by aylmao on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @11:08PM (#19569014)
Each person's, hopefully.