Re:Ask HN: Please upvote good questions in comments
by scott_s on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @07:09PM
(#1956174)
It's a soft distinction, one of implication. I think we have discussions here. I think of "comments" as shouting in the ether, and that's usually not what we do.
I disagree that the series of questions will necessarily result in a better understanding. Any meaningful set of questions will involve two-way communication for clarification, which quickly becomes what I call a discussion. Debate and interview are different, but I think HN comment threads are neither.
I frequently see questions in HN threads. I sometimes ask them.
I disagree that the series of questions will necessarily result in a better understanding. Any meaningful set of questions will involve two-way communication for clarification, which quickly becomes what I call a discussion. Debate and interview are different, but I think HN comment threads are neither.
I frequently see questions in HN threads. I sometimes ask them.