Here's what is being exchanged:
Hi, I have lots of followers (to my knowledge they are not bots themselves) that I can present advertisements to. Many of them are either interested in NYC or located here. Would you like to
Ie: let's exchange visibility (for this target group) for perks.
This is the basis of advertising, just that perks is money. It's not the person asking for money who might be an idiot, it's the person paying if the value provided does not match. And frankly exchanging visibility for perks instead of money is extremely cheap for restaurants. If the value does not match what the restaurant was after, they can not accept such proposals anymore.
There's risk in being in business, you just have to accept that.
Regardless of where we draw the line for "disingenuous," You can't seriously be suggested that only people in the US come up with such schemes. A recent thread (yesterday) on Another Site (I'm sure you've read it - the site, but not the thread) that indicated to me visiting places around the world is a fine way to get fleeced by individuals (locals, not Americans) with disingenuous schemes.
This gets really, really tiresome after a while.
Maybe I have different values, not having grown up in the US of A, but I don't think I could ever pull off such a disingenuous enterprise.
Edit: OP literally admits to stealing content. I could see something similar to this being more legitimate, but this is not it. (For the record the insta is @beautiful.[redacted] and almost all of the followers are bots)