Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by analognoise on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:36AM
(#19551862)
Verilator has some serious limitations:
It is a terrible recommendation for beginners - you'd be much better served by using Xilinx Vivado's inbuilt simulator and waveform viewer.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by orbifold on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @04:39AM
(#19552145)
It has a steep learning curve, but overall I think it forces you to adopt good development practices from the start. Since it generates C++ you can also easily wrap that code and expose it to python. That way you can use software tools instead of system verilog and can easily do integration testing with your software HAL. In practice our group uses commercial tools (synopsis, cadence) and DPI-C but for the most part this is because of the VHDL code we have. Vivado‘s build in simulator is way too slow.
Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by q3k on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @07:48AM
(#19553039)
The first two are a feature for me. Not to mention not being crippled by Xilinx 'IP Core' DRM.
Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by analognoise on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @04:42PM
(#19558371)
Crippled by extant, available code which is shipping in millions of devices?
Is it perfect? Hell no. But it's a bit drastic to throw out an entire catalog of the most battle-tested HDL code in the world, isn't it?
Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by _chris_ on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:30PM
(#19557760)
> It requires Gtkwave to view waveforms with (opinion, but I hate the UI)
It dumps a value-change file (vcd) which can be viewed by anything, no? Sure it's not very compressed (and the compile-time for vcd-generation is unfortunate), but it's not a show-stopper.
Re:Verilator: Fast, Free Verilog HDL Simulator
by analognoise on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:58PM
(#19557986)
This is correct; although I am unaware of a FOSS vcd viewer which improves upon Gtkwave.
I would be exceedingly happy to find one, however; please let me know.