News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by rb808 on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:22PM (#19548392)
"So the rocket launch is planned for October, will the software be ready?"

"Not sure, the software developer team doesn't like deadlines, they'll be finished when they feel like it."

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by freddie_mercury on Monday April 01, 2019 @08:24PM (#19549798)
I'd make a related argument:

When people are producers they don't like deadlines but as soon as they are consumers they demand them.

Go build a house and you'll be constantly asking "when will it be done" and "whenever" isn't acceptable to you.

Order something from Amazon and "it'll arrive whenever it arrives" isn't acceptable to you.

Sell some stocks and ask your broker when you'll get the cash and "whenever, in a few days, not sure man, asking me about dates really takes me out of my Flow State" doesn't sound so great.

We want deadlines. We want to know when our iPhone will be repaired, when our drycleaning will be done, when our children's schooling will be done for the day, when our plane will take off, when our car repair will be done, when the movie will start, and so on.

I always find that these kinds of articles can too often come across as "deadlines for you, but not for me" if they don't really grapple with that reality and try to come up with explanations for the dichotomy.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by Macross8299 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:04PM (#19550703)
In addition to this, to narrow the scope strictly within software engineering, I don't think too many people on HN would sign an employment contract that states that cash will be paid or equity vested "whenever".

So why the hate for deadlines? Software engineering does not exist in vacuum separated from business constraints like runway or annual budgets. To demand deadlines of your employer but to not be willing to even try to meet deadlines in deliverables seems to me to be a bit unprofessional and disconnected from the underlying business reality. A whole company that wants to shrug off this underlying business reality seems even worse. A series B startup that doesn't meet deadlines might not even be in business in 6 months.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by closeparen on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:16PM (#19550454)
If you understand a software task well enough to profile, optimize, and make correct predictions about it (the way UPS does with package delivery, or Lennar with exurb manufacturing), you understand it well enough to build a reusable solution. If you have good architecture and code reuse, the share of time that a team spends on well-understood tasks with accurate estimates should approach zero. Software scales - that's the point.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by freddie_mercury on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:27PM (#19550517)
This response strikes me as a typical "software development is so special we have to live by different rules" response that developers all too frequently make. Software development is not as special we often make it out to be.

Building a house is the same, yet we want our builder to tell us deadlines and get upset when he misses them.

All infrastructure work is the same, yet we gleefully complain about how that subway/overpass/bridge/new airport is behind schedule.

Medicine is the same, but we become (extremely!) upset when our doctor is 60 minutes late to our appointment and we have to wait.

Teaching is the same, but we'd flip out if our teacher decided to keep kids an extra 20 minutes and we're waiting outside in our car to pick them up.

Heck, just look at how upset people get about how long it takes George R.R. Martin or Patrick Rothfuss to write their next books!

I guarantee many of the same people complaining about George R.R. Martin taking so long also complain about their boss asking for estimates and setting deadlines.

And on and on and on.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by closeparen on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:59AM (#19554119)
People can want estimates and deadlines, but the estimates won’t be correct and the deadlines won’t be met for an ambitious custom build house, a subway tunnel through unknown “legacy,” or a diagnosis and treatment of an exotic disease, because that’s not how it works.

They might be correct for overpass #10,000, build #300 of Standard House Model B, or churning out antibiotic prescriptions. But those projects should cease to require much if any engineering support, leaving only the ones with more unknowns.

Subway tunneling is a really great example. You run into underground infrastructure that wasn’t in the documentation and you have to stop and figure out whether it’s still used, what it’s connected to, etc. and either refactor it out of your way or change your own route before continuing. You don’t know in advance how many such situations you’ll run into or how difficult they’ll be to untangle. So subway projects are chronically late and over budget.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by swish_bob on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @05:23AM (#19552347)
Building houses is an excellent example. When a large corporation is building an estate, the time and cost taken to build the houses is fairly well known, and consistently accurate (to a degree).

Custom/self builds are famously hard to predict, and nearly always go massively over budget and over time (twice as long, twice as much is more common than on budget, on schedule). Often because there are significant changes to the requirements as the project goes on, because the customer changes their mind, or because unexpected things are discovered during the build.

In fact, with the arguable exception of teaching, which is a classic example of deliver to deadline with no specific set of features, all of your examples are things that people are unable to accurately predict.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by marcosdumay on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:26PM (#19548978)
"So, will the rocket control software be ready by October?"

"Yes, it will. But we can't guarantee it will work correctly."

Choose your poison.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by dannersk on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:07PM (#19548816)
Hmm, this doesn't seem like a good argument. Would you really rush that kind of thing if the developer team was not feeling good about the state of the software? Not always, but sometimes failure can be much worse than late.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by whatshisface on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:27PM (#19548452)
What fraction of developers work on rockets versus A/B testing signup button colors?
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by kingnothing on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:49PM (#19548665)
"So the marketing for our new product has to be purchased 3 months in advance to tie in for the TV ads, magazine ads, bus stop ads, and web buys. Not to mention we need to work with legal, and our CEO needs to talk to the board. When the devs be done?"
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by i_can_c_sharp on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:15PM (#19548893)
In 3-5 weeks (change to months for a bigger project). Don’t buy the ad until it’s in production. Use the 3 months to iron out tha bugs that will be found in production.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by flukus on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:02PM (#19549254)
Is there some rule that the product has to be available for sale and advertised as soon as the code rolls off the production line? Why can't they begin scheduling these things when the code is 90%+ done? It's not going to rust or go stale while marketing gears up, having a completely different business unit driving you're release process is just a recipe for releasing buggy shit.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by _AzMoo on Monday April 01, 2019 @08:13PM (#19549739)
If you're developing something novel and it's not deployed as it's completed you risk a competitor beating you to market. As well as this, the time between having a product or feature complete and ready for release equates to lost revenue. The ideal is to have all aspects of the project completed and ready for deployment (actual feature, supporting documentation, training materials, marketing campaigns and materials, etc.) at the same time to maximise possible revenue.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by flukus on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:59PM (#19550976)
> If you're developing something novel and it's not deployed as it's completed you risk a competitor beating you to market.

If you're competitor is imminently releasing a competing product then what you're working on isn't really novel. It would also be potentially patentable if it really was novel, which would grant you a monopoly on the space.

> As well as this, the time between having a product or feature complete and ready for release equates to lost revenue.

What's the lost revenue from releasing a buggy product? What's the lost revenue if your competitors are about to release a working one? What's the lost revenue from your developers jumping ship and all the related turn over costs? Some of those mistakes could sink the product/business entirely.

> to maximise possible revenue.

You agree that maximizing revenue at the expense of everything else isn't the goal don't you? If that's all that mattered then development would be outsourced to a third world country to save on expenses. But we've mostly learned no to do that because despite promising revenue gains they lead to several bad outcomes in the short and long term, pushing hard deadlines is no different.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by NeoBasilisk on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:26PM (#19548441)
Most of us are not writing space shuttle code (or any other aerospace code, considering all space shuttles have been retired).
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by rb808 on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:30PM (#19548490)
Changed to rocket.

Most of us aren't writing code that will go to space, but most of us work with other parts of the business, and marketing, management, investors need agreed deadlines to coordinate with.

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by bostonvaulter2 on Monday April 01, 2019 @08:07PM (#19549696)
No, but the bootloader will be! We can just send up the final image once the satellite is in space.
Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by prewett on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @02:33AM (#19551554)
I think that's how NASA develops their longer-range probes, like Cassini and New Horizons. It's something like a six year journey to Saturn, so plenty of development time after the launch.

But that bootloader had better be flawless!

Re:Deadlines Are Killing Us, and Almost Everything Else I Kn... by vbuwivbiu on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:15AM (#19551750)
"a^n + b^n = c^n, can you prove this by October ?"