News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by reaperducer on Saturday March 30, 2019 @07:02AM (#19528830)
Except that if you know anything about how newspapers work, the Gell-Mann theory falls apart.

It only works if every article in a newspaper is written by the same person with the same level of knowledge and ignorance of every topic published. This simply isn’t the case, as newspapers are written by dozens or hundreds of different people working for many different companies and with many different backgrounds.

For example, a new reporter who bones a story about a local car factory has absolutely no bearing on the accuracy of the work of a seasoned reporter for a wire service covering politics in the nation’s capitol a thousand miles away.

Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by danShumway on Saturday March 30, 2019 @08:24AM (#19529056)
Well, wait a sec.

It does have a bearing on the overall editorial quality of the paper, unless as a reader you can figure out a predictable reason for editorial quality to drop for only one specific topic. It means that a poorly researched article can get out of the door without being flagged.

Individual articles of clothing, food, and other products coming out of a company are inspected by different people. But when I go to Wendy's and buy some fries, I don't know which people are inspecting and preparing my food, and know who was preparing my food wouldn't be useful unless I already knew a lot about that person. If I went to a restaurant and my fries had mold on them, it would probably be the fault of a small percentage of the workers there. But I would still be justified in distrusting the rest of my food, even if I thought the rest of the food on my plate was probably prepared by different people.

I don't know enough about the individual staff members of my local newspaper or their individual contributions to each article to make an educated distinction between them. If I see evidence that my overall newspaper is willing to publish badly researched articles, it seems very logical to me to conclude, "hey, when you see an article in a subject you're not familiar with, remember that it might be one of the duds. If you see an article by a reporter you're not already familiar with, remember that they were hired by a newspaper that occasionally hires bad reporters."

Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by Yetanfou on Saturday March 30, 2019 @08:29AM (#19529069)
While this is true, it is often also the case that the people writing about certain areas are not necessarily experts in those areas. I have personal experience with this phenomenon as I used to write for and edit a number of IT-related magazines. In that capacity I went to a lot of press meetings, conferences and other similar gatherings where I mingled with my colleagues from other publications. It was striking to notice how little knowledge many of them actually possessed about the - often deeply technical - subjects being discussed and even more striking to see that they nevertheless wrote articles full of mumbo-jumbo which got published in their outlets which' readers can be assumed to have turned to those with the intent of being informed on those subjects.

Being able to write a fluent story is a skill in itself and not necessarily linked to deep knowledge about the subjects the story touches. News publications work off deadlines where it can be - no, strike that, is - most important to have something, anything to publish. Those who can reliably produce the required few paragraphs will rise higher than those who put accuracy above timeliness.

Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by reaperducer on Saturday March 30, 2019 @06:15PM (#19532267)
it is often also the case that the people writing about certain areas are not necessarily experts in those areas.

This is not a secret. It's basic journalism. Beat reporting hasn't been common since the 1970's. Almost all journalists are expected to be generalists. Today it's a car crash. Tomorrow it's a labor strike. It's the nature of the business.

Daily news isn't for in-depth research. That's what books, documentaries, and other slow media is for. The daily news is for reporting the news of the day.

Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by Yetanfou on Saturday March 30, 2019 @07:42PM (#19532699)
> Daily news isn't for in-depth research. That's what books, documentaries, and other slow media is for. The daily news is for reporting the news of the day.

...but what about weekly and monthly news? That was the publishing frequency for most of the publications in this area. Those were the magazines those people wrote for, often not hindered by any deep knowledge about the subject matter but gifted with a quick pen - not to mention the advertising department which wanted to keep their clients happy.

Re:GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6 by reaperducer on Saturday March 30, 2019 @10:58PM (#19533496)
It depends on the publication and the geography. It's hard to detail the operations of the entire media industry in a HN comment.