In WWII, F4 Wildcat pilots soon learned not to get into turning contests with Mitsubishi Zeros. Instead, they maintained altitude and speed, using their advantage in a dive to execute "slashing" attacks.
something that looks like a DJI phantom...the only way I seem them being useful is 1000 of them in a dense cloud around a target.. like stationary mines in the sky hoping to be struck by attackers like a bird strike.
Those drones are plenty fast enough for tanks. Why not a tank equivalent of an aircraft carrier? The tank would act as a mobile charging station and command center. Most modern tanks could be severely disabled by a shaped charge placed directly onto the barrel of the main gun, or directly onto the tread mechanism. The machine guns and targeting systems are also quite vulnerable, the loss of which would also severely degrade the tank's combat power. Tanks have acquired countermeasure systems like Trophy, but those could be overwhelmed through saturation attacks and on current tanks, they are externally mounted and themselves vulnerable.
Fun trivia that I read a while back: After getting hold of a zero, they discovered that the carburetor design would cause the engine to sputter on high speed dives. https://www.history.com/news/the-akutan-zero-how-a-captured-...
Also, their controls could become sluggish at the right conditions near their top speeds.
If such a vehicle could operate without infantry support, it might be worth doing the R&D.
And all of that is only in case you haven't already been hacked or spied on by other means.
There were a few public talks on youtube from relevant engineers about other possible countermeasures but I can't find them now. But the summary is that while war planes take 20 years to build, most countermeasures can be coded and iterated in a week on some existing platform as new info becomes available. Usually in the form of coordinating a swarm in certain ways and synthesising radio signals for different purposes.
Agreed, and that's what scares me the most. All drones "pilots" will safely return to their families, their families won't lose any loved ones, therefore they'll become even easier to brainwash into voting anyone who supports wars. Circle closed, war becomes a 24/7/365 business worldwide and if you happen to live in the wrong place you're pretty much screwed.
It's also important to note that in the last few decades very few US pilots have been shot down or killed, so switching to drones doesn't significantly change the equation. The majority of the dying is going to be from the infantry on the ground, which aren't going anywhere anytime soon.
http://web.archive.org/web/20160217174724/https://squid314.l...
Put like this, it really makes you wonder if drone warfare is the worse alternative.
and we're back to missiles. those are just missiles. next you'll invent MIRVs under the premise of saving on the cost of the "cruising" since targets tend to be clustered.
F-35 is not air superiority fighter, so it has no speed or acceleration to leave the chasing aircraft behind after it has launched the missiles.
In general, one of the things that sets the F22/F35 apart from most of the competition is their AESA phased array radar, which is allegedly the best in the world. It can find enemy aircraft long before they can find it. Also, it can allow the pilot to lock and fire missiles before the enemy is close enough to target it. The dogfighting days where men such as the Red Barron or Chuck Yaeger ruled the skies are pretty much done forever. Soon enough we'll have UCAVs which can do > 12G rolls and will win every single dogfight because turns that fast cause humans to simply lose consciousness.
These aren't inconsistent arguments, but one wonders how far down the turtles go and how much we're willing to pay.
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/f-35-beast-mode-new-v...
I think I the balance is to use each platform for what it is amazing at and supplement the weaknesses with other platforms that are better in various areas. Combined forces hit the hardest, but the electronics / SIGINT packages in modern fighters truly does set them apart. After an F35 has expended all of its rockets it can still designate targets for other combatants to destroy. The sensor fusion going on (thanks to Moore’s law and smaller / faster compute) really is something.
That seems incredibly underwhelming. Isn't that less than the capacity of a single ground based vehicle?
And wouldn't a fixed position defensive system have hundreds of missiles?
I can't quite see when four bombs per mission is ever going to be "an unbelievable amount of firepower".
Let's compare that to one of the more recent Soviet air superiority fighters, the Su-57[1]. For air-to-air combat, it has 4 beyond visual range missiles and 2 short range missiles. The F35 in beast mode has 16 (14 long range and 2 short range) air to air missiles in addition to its machine gun. Pretty big difference even excluding the massively better AESA phased array radars in the F35 and additional jamming / spoofing hw in the F35.
It might seem underwhelming to you, but it is still an overwhelming amount of firepower. A ground based vehicle doesn't need to be stealth or deal with gravity. Ground based vehicles also don't need to go supersonic whereas the F35 can go mach 1.6. The US anti-aircraft patriot missile launcher, the M901, can be loaded with 4 PAC-2 patriots for anti-air, or 16 PAC-3 patriots for shooting down ballistic missiles. Do they keep some extra missiles with each unit to reload? Absolutely! Hundreds? Not even close. We worked with them when I was a UAV Pilot (Shadow 200 TUAV aka a "drone" that was about 11'x13'x2.5ft).
What I can tell you, from experience, is that when a single bomb can literally level a city block, four bombs per mission is an unbelievable amount of firepower. For serious missions, you'll also have entire wings of planes continuously dropping ordinance, flying back to base, rearming and doing it again. You end up with a lot of destruction, but this is real life and not a video game. I flew many missions in OIF II (482 combat flight hours) on the reconnaissance drone the Shadow 200. We did a lot of targeting and one of the more memorable missions involved a Kiowa scout helicopter being shot down. They made a military channel special about it[2] and what ended it was dropping a single GBU50 500lb bomb on a huge weapon cache the militants were using to rearm before trying to blow up the downed chopper and the pilots time and time again.
For a huge and daring operation to blow up a lot of Syria's chemical weapon production facilities look at the number of planes involved. Note that Syria has the S200 and newer Pantsir, supposedly some of the best anti-air in the world. The mission was a total success with all targeted facilities destroyed and not a single allied plane shot down.
Does this maybe answer your question? It might not seem like a lot, but these can be very big bombs and it isn't as though the enemy is spread evenly over a city the size of New York City.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sukhoi_Su-57#Armament
[2] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0845577/
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_missile_strikes_against_S...
I'd envision "kamikaze" drones being the most feasible
thing to be effective first. Basically much smarter
missiles. A vision of a swarm of something..
Reminds me of this foreboding demonstration of micro drone kamikaze assassinations:1. https://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/why-boeings-design-for-a-7...
2. https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/aircraft/sys...
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_P-8_Poseidon
4. https://www.reddit.com/r/MilitaryPorn/comments/1b5tyd/kawasa...
The main downside that I can think of is that you really need air superiority to use them effectively, because they can't outfight, outmaneuver, or run away from any sort of enemy fighter. That's not a big deal against ISIS, but it's no good for prospective conflicts with China or Russia or whatever. Also, modern tactics tend more towards precision strikes rather than massive carpet bombing or, God forbid, nukes.
Modern combat is not at all the same thing as WWI/WWII "turn and burn" stuff or what gets depicted in Star Wars.
"Turn and Burn" was already out of favor with US pilots in WWII.
If the F-35 enters into a turn-and-burn in a 3-1 situation the pilot has already failed.. if he gets out of the situation alive he's getting chewed out.
They have all kinds of training & procedures around different scenarios and those don't involve flying straight at the enemy and then getting into a turning match.
We haven't seen the deployment of a drone which can threaten manned aircraft yet. That's going to be fascinating to watch.
I'd envision "kamikaze" drones being the most feasible thing to be effective first. Basically much smarter missiles. A vision of a swarm of something that looks like a DJI phantom threatening fixed wing aircraft is pretty much fantasy right now though. Too slow, not enough weight capacity, range & loitering time & service ceiling too low, etc.. the only way I seem them being useful is 1000 of them in a dense cloud around a target.. like stationary mines in the sky hoping to be struck by attackers like a bird strike.