Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by kj12345 on Monday November 29, 2010 @07:31PM
(#1952501)
However in a truly competitive commodity market (and surely bits moving from A to B are a perfect example of a commodity), "charge by cost" and "charge by value" should converge, and when they don't we should be alarmed. If ISP X is making 1% profit on regular bits and then decides to make 10% on premium bits, why couldn't ISP Y come along and undercut them? Because the market is being manipulated through monopolies on infrastructure and lobbying for special treatment.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by alttab on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:06AM
(#1954097)
This truly is the clearest articulation of the economic danger of net neutrality I've ever heard.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by jerf on Monday November 29, 2010 @09:15PM
(#1952757)
Good argument, but you've got the main point backwards. Byte-for-byte people will value the email more. It's an incredibly economical use of bandwidth. A given 64KB chunk of my video may not even arrive and it's just a momentary annoyance in the stream, if not entirely error-corrected away.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by alttab on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:08AM
(#1954103)
Proof in point: When IT blocks YouTube, the slackers groan. but if the exchange server goes down...
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by jrockway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:49AM
(#1954675)
Nobody would mind Exchange being down if Youtube was available :)
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by jerf on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @01:30PM
(#1955061)
After further consideration of your argument, I stand corrected.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by amalcon on Monday November 29, 2010 @08:14PM
(#1952617)
Everyone prefers to sell on value. Everyone prefers to buy on cost. Which end it falls on reflects who has the stronger negotiating position. More money can be extracted from the video bandwidth in a world where the person buying the bandwidth doesn't have another option.
In what world can you extract more cash from 65536 octets representing a video than 65536 octets representing an email? A world where end users value them differently.