In Westminster, voting usually happens by each MP physically moving into one of two lobbies. That is a very time consuming process, that can easily take twenty minutes per vote. There are no ballots, let alone a computerised voting system.
That the recent indicative votes happened on paper is extraordinarily modern. Preferential voting would clearly be a step too far.
I believe that's planned for Monday
It's not. It's for completely pragmatic reasons.
The bind they're in is that, even if they select a winner, the process doesn't stop there. There will be subsequent votes on primary and related legislation to pass before we're completed.
Unless there is a majority for a way forward, or enough MPs are willing to concede that their objections aren't actually principled, much of that legislation is likely not not pass.
And, to my understanding, there were discussions about priority voting for the alternatives. It is conceivable that that will still occur. But it just moves the intractability to a different stage (much like splitting out the political declaration is doing).
When that fails, this.
I believe this is the plan for Monday if the PM's deal doesn't go through today. I.e. list the options you will accept in order of preference.
It’s slightly risky but overall seems like a reasonable approach to me, in the circumstances.
Voting against your PM on an issue you disagree on is one thing. Actually bringing down your government is quite another.
There should have been an election already. I think it was dishonest not to bring down the government in the recent vote of No Confidence, since it was and is blatantly obvious that absolutely nobody has confidence in Theresa May’s government. But they feared letting Labour in.
Edit to add: I would have thought some emergency compromise might work, eg a moderate Tory who backs the consensus plan as PM, maybe Corbyn as deputy, maybe Keir Starmer as Brexit secretary. Get the Brexit process on an even keel now, agree to call an election later.
That’s probably unthinkable on all sides, though. I feel like Corbyn in particular doesn’t actually care much about Brexit either way, and is much more focused on just winning an election and getting a Labour government in.
Or more specifically they fear letting Corbin in. I imagine that if a more center-left, pro-Europe 'Blairite' MP was Labour leader then perhaps some of the more moderate pro-Europe Conservatives might have been willing to give it a punt.
If the deal isn’t passed today, the April 12th deadline is for the UK to come up with a new suggestion.
If the deal fails, the UK could request a longer extension, or even revoke article 50.
The EU has strongly signaled that they’d be open to adjusting the political declaration in favour of a customs union, for example. If the UK were to vote for that early next week, it could in principle be agreed on both sides fairly quickly.
The main EU requirement is that to avoid a no-deal exit on April 12, the UK has to actually do something different, not simply ask for more time. If the UK requested time for a general election or a second referendum, that would probably be accepted by the EU (although it’s not guaranteed).
--
Edit: See comments below - I got the dates wrong.
With a deal, the deadline is May, allowing time for some of the necessary domestic legislation.
Deadlines April 12 -- if mays deal has passed, extended to May 22 to allow domestic legislation to be passed to implement the deal
If not passed by then, then uk leaves with no deal
However May's government can ask for an extension at any point up until April 12th. This extension will rely on the UK participating in the EU elections. Those elections can be held if announced by or on April 12th -- there's a reason it's that day and not April 3rd or 19th.
It's almost certain we'll be looking at a long delay, and either a referendum or general election
I agree, but how many legislatures around the world actually work like that? Certainly not the UK or USA.
Who knows, maybe this fiasco will spur on voting reform in the UK parliament! Apparently they already use STV for committee positions, so it’s not unthinkable. I thought Wednesday’s use of approval voting in the main House was a very promising step in the right direction.
So it’s enough to find a majority for the method/process, and the selection of options to use. There is no need for a majority for a single option.
So at no point would there be anything but normal yes/no votes with normal majority requirement in the legal sense.
It’s a bit like how some US states can agree to put their electoral college votes to the majority winner.
The bar is (sadly) very low for people to say “this voting system is too complicated, nobody will understand it!”
You say “Condorcet” as if that’s a complete solution, but there could be a preference cycle with no way to break it. You’d need to pick a specific method, like STV, and every method has flaws.
This is a very intense situation, where many people feel like they’re under intense pressure, with very short deadlines. On top of that, it’s being done in public, and everybody is juggling multiple concerns (doing the right thing in the short term versus long term, helping the country, helping their party... Being seen to help their country and/or party, protecting their own careers, etc etc)
Overall I think it’d be very difficult and risky for Parliament to adopt even a slightly novel voting system at the last minute, even to resolve a major crisis.
Yet they seen convinced that the only thing they can do is do yes/no votes to reach a majority for one of the N alternatives. If this is for legal/constitutional reasons (it most likely is) then it’s a horrible mistake to not have realized this and corrected it.
Parliament needs a simple and legal way to swiftly select the most popular option among N options where none have a majority. This isn’t a dangerous legal loophole - the acceptance of such an N-way tie and the selection of the N options can still be decided with majority.
There should be a ranked or Condorcet vote and the winner should be enacted. It should have happened a year ago at least.