News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by scarface74 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:47PM (#19516968)
>I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university.

I think you kind of just made the point. Why would I pay for something that isn’t practical?

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by zbentley on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:53PM (#19517007)
Because what may prove practical over a long term may not do so in the short or medium term.

And because what counts as “practicality” changes as people progress through their careers, but the foundations required to meet each new standard of what counts as practical often remain the same (or change less).

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by ghaff on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:14PM (#19517161)
That's perhaps the key point. I have engineering degrees (not CS) yet I work for a software tech company and do a lot of things that are much more about a broader liberal arts education and extracurricular activities than they are about specific technical courses I took. And, even when I did work as an engineer, it mostly wasn't in an area where I directly applied coursework.
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by scarface74 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @09:17PM (#19518314)
And my business courses have helped a lot more in both undergrad and as an MBA dropout.

Most of us are working to increase business value for companies - either by making them money or by saving them money. They could care less about “Cracking the Code” and LeetCode.

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by scarface74 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @09:15PM (#19518304)
As long as I have been doing this professionally - over 2 decades and before that 10 years as a hobbyist writing 65C02 assembly and C. I can honestly say that at this point in my career, the computer science part of what I learned hasn’t really helped me besides one course in data structures. That was only because I spent over a decade doing C.

Most developers won’t be doing that these days.

As my career has progressed, it’s moved further away and at higher levels of abstractions. These days even hardware is abstracted behind an API with cloud providers.

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by danpat on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:56PM (#19517023)
I think "non-practical" was perhaps poor wording.

I assume what the parent meant was a "data structures and algorithms" course, compared with say, "How to code in Java using the standard library".

The latter is "practical" - you can take what you learn and churn out code in Java.

The former is "non-practical" - you can't make the theories you now understand function without a practical implementation. But you can recognize the implementation in any environment, and understand its implications.

The general assertion is that an understanding of the "non-practical" will serve you longer than a purely "practical" education. I tend to agree.

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by MaxBarraclough on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:04AM (#19535930)
Well put. Yes, I might have phrased that better.

A concrete example: My firewall rule is set to deny all incoming TCP connections except those originating from port 80, and destined for port 80. Why is it blocking all my HTTP connection attempts?

If you understand TCP, you'll understanding that we shouldn't be filtering on source port at all. If you have only the vague sort of understanding that comes from using a technology in practice but never having properly studied it, you might have no idea.

And yet I'd still count that as 'non-practical knowledge'. It isn't something you're ever going to apply 'directly', unless you're one of the handful of people implementing their own TCP stack.

There's similar value in studying complexity theory (why does this seemingly simple code take so long?), operating system fundamentals (aren't containers and VMs roughly the same though?), and compilers (for a deeper appreciation of programming in general, and, my personal favourite, to instil a due sense of terror regarding undefined behaviour in C-family languages).

Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by Nouser76 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:58PM (#19517034)
While not everything learned in an undergraduate computer science program is practical in the sense that you'll use it all the time in the real world, there are a fair number of topics that while not necessary 99% of the time turn out to be the best solution that other 1% of the time. Finite state automata, for example, isn't something I'd bother to learn about but has proven helpful a handful of times.
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by dragandj on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:04PM (#19517094)
You pay for many things in life that are not practical. Why would you expect from education to be 100% practical?
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by SamReidHughes on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:06PM (#19517103)
If practicality doesn't matter, why not study Pokémon?
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by zeroimpl on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:27PM (#19517264)
There’s a lot of numbers between 0 and 100...
Re:Forget Bribery – The Real Scam Is Pretending That Degrees... by walshemj on Thursday March 28, 2019 @07:32PM (#19517704)
Why have you have not learnt to code at high school if you wanted to do CS