News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by maxerickson on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:58AM (#19513453)
Yes, it seemed you were arguing those two numbers could easily be encoded using existing words.

If you want to make gibberish word like objects it's probably possible.

Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by mirimir on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:26PM (#19513725)
But what's the point of that?

If they were always the same two (or three) words, fine.

But if there are multiple such encoding systems, any set of three words (foo.bar.baz) is ambiguous. Because it depends on the system being used.

So sure, someone might remember "foo.bar.baz". But "foo.bar.baz" in W3W might be in SF. But in Hanoi by some other system.

And then we get to the need to pay W3W to generate those codes. That's crazy bullshit.

Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by NikkiA on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:34PM (#19515737)
TBF The maidenhead system (which is a worldwide standard) IS, IMO fairly easy to remember.

And because it's pairs are increasing in area, I can state that I live in IO93 and it narrows it to:

https://www.karhukoti.com/maidenhead-grid-square-locator/?gr...

or I could give the next 2 characters to narrow it to a 1km x 1km (roughly) area that covers my town, or the 2 letters and 2 numbers that give a small area that pinpoints 2-3 houses on my street.

It's not really any more complex or hard to remember than a standard postal code or zip code.

Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by mirimir on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:50PM (#19515881)
Now that sounds like a very useful system. It's hierarchical. With arbitrary precision. With ~short, easy to remember (and easy to key/speak on radio) codes. Nice.
Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by maxerickson on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:29PM (#19513763)
Yes, W3W is stupid, but each address is a pointer to lots o bits.
Re:Why Bother with What Three Words? by mirimir on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:29PM (#19513761)
Words in one language are very often ~gibberish words in other languages. And worse, because of false homonyms. And people with heavy accents.