Re:Keybase is not softer than TOFU
by godelski on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:14AM
(#19509460)
> If I tell you that X secure and ...
Is Signal or WA in that regime? Literally the only reason I don't use WA is because it is owned by FB. But as far as I'm aware both are cryptographically secure. Yes, I'm aware WA has a metadata problem.
So what's good enough? I'd say that if you need a state actor to crack it, I'll call it good enough. At least for the general populous. Any more difficulty that can be made is a bonus imo.
Clearly we can't get a perfect e2e app. So at what point in time do we say "we also need other features that people want so that they'll use our app". That doesn't mean "stop working on encryption" (you can never stop that) but "we're at a good enough point to start targeting a larger market." I think something like Signal is there. Stop focusing on the security geeks and bring in the general public.
Is Signal or WA in that regime? Literally the only reason I don't use WA is because it is owned by FB. But as far as I'm aware both are cryptographically secure. Yes, I'm aware WA has a metadata problem.
So what's good enough? I'd say that if you need a state actor to crack it, I'll call it good enough. At least for the general populous. Any more difficulty that can be made is a bonus imo.
Clearly we can't get a perfect e2e app. So at what point in time do we say "we also need other features that people want so that they'll use our app". That doesn't mean "stop working on encryption" (you can never stop that) but "we're at a good enough point to start targeting a larger market." I think something like Signal is there. Stop focusing on the security geeks and bring in the general public.