News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by rayiner on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @10:16PM (#19508540)
Ever since we created a huge glut of phds by encouraging people to go into fields that have no market demand. Next question. (Fun fact: those underemployed professors are just teaching the next generation of underemployed academics. It’s turtles all the way down.)
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by jccalhoun on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:15PM (#19508879)
That is certainly part of it. As someone with a phd in a field with no market demand I tell anyone with doubts about whether they want to go to grad school not to. However, there is also the immense growth in adjuncts and non-tenure positions. In the last department I was in there were 5 tenure track positions, 4-5 people on three year contracts (which they have since cut back on) and like 10 of us that were either on one year contracts (which the school eliminated which led to me getting my current job) or "part time" faculty that they didn't have to pay benefits.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by shhehebehdh on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:39PM (#19509011)
You say “however”, but doesn’t this just reflect the same problem? There are a lot of people with phds who want these jobs, so they are willing to accept these adjunct positions. In the past, when there were fewer excess phds, nobody would have accepted a position under these terms.

Personally, I have no problem with professors getting paid less. My only objection is that these savings don’t appear to be passed on to students. When we get much more efficient at manufacturing computer hardware, one of the benefits is that anyone can buy a capable device for $300 or less. But when we get more efficient at generating phds, and therefore have a much greater supply of teachers, the savings are not apparent in tuition prices.

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by veryworried on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:15AM (#19509190)
Tuition will not drop until we see a tightening on student loans. As long as lenders are giving out vast sums of money to kids with no job and no credit, there is no reason to drop tuition prices.

Higher tuition wouldn’t really be a problem if it weren’t for the fact that many people who take on these massive debts are later unable to secure high paying jobs that let them pay it off in a timely fashion, turning them into debt slaves for the better part of their life (or maybe all of it). That’s the risk you take though.

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by cmurf on Thursday March 28, 2019 @02:11AM (#19509688)
Or if student loans were dischargeable in bankruptcy.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by veryworried on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:25AM (#19522469)
Too late for that now. These debts can never be discharged without grave consequences for the economy.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by jccalhoun on Thursday March 28, 2019 @08:07AM (#19511338)
In the department I was in I was the only non-tenure track person with a phd. All the others only had masters degrees. That is, of course, only one department so may not be representative of other departments. And often it would be difficult to find people to teach the courses. Because there was a limit to how many courses a person could be taught and still be "part-time" the full time, non-tenure track, faculty often ended up teaching extra courses.

Regarding tuition costs, there are a lot of reasons why it has grown so quickly. One is the growth in administration. When my old university announced they wouldn't be doing any more one year contracts and would instead be going with exclusively part-time faculty, I suggested they look into part-time administrators but they didn't seem to think that was a good idea...

Another is the escalating "arms race" of campus amenities. Four year universities feel like they need to add more and more and fancier and fancier amenities to attract students because they feel like if they don't have a new multi-million dollar rec center and the nearby college does that students will be more likely to go to the other college.

A third reason is that the funds colleges get from states is a smaller percentage of their budget now than it was in the past. One of my friends is an advisor at a Big Ten college and she recently posted on facebook that she was going through some old paperwork that had been left in her office and found the university's budget for 1997. Comparing it to 2019, the university's budget had doubled but the amount of money that it received from the state had only increased by about 25%. That money has to come from somewhere (which is one reason why that university has made a big push to attract international students in recent years since they pay a lot more in tuition than in-state students)

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by lacey on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:57AM (#19509397)
I recall reading an article several years ago where they pointed out that 50% of PhD candidates in Biology who were surveyed were hoping for tenure track positions in academia. The other 50% expected to go elsewhere. Of the 50% wanting a tenure-track position, the expectation was that there were enough positions available for 1/6th of them.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by pfdietz on Thursday March 28, 2019 @08:15AM (#19511395)
My daughter has had a strong interest in biological subjects, but when we talked about careers some years back we both agreed that going for a PhD would be a bad move. She was more interested in medicine, and that's turned out to be a much better career path.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by godzillabrennus on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @10:25PM (#19508606)
I believe their titles are “indentured servants” given that they will owe tons of student loans.
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by krastanov on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:22AM (#19509497)
While it is common to pay tuition for your undergraduate degree or maybe even your master degree, PhD students are typically paid for their teaching and research work and their tuition is covered (admittedly the salaries are low).
Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:29AM (#19509525)
Market-demand tends to be a very short-sighted way of organising a society.

You'd think we'd want more and more researchers in general, even if their research doesn't immediately turn into a marketable product.

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by tatersolid on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:47AM (#19510161)
Note many/most of these excess PhDs are not “researchers” in the pure sciences.

We’re talking bout PhDs in fields like “environmental psychology” as mentioned in the article.

Such invented pursuits have minimal societal benefit. It’s unsurprising that society is unwilling to subsidize many tenured positions in the study of bullshit.

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by speedplane on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:55AM (#19510193)
> We’re talking bout PhDs in fields like “environmental psychology” as mentioned in the article. Such invented pursuits have minimal societal benefit.

From the internet: "Environmental psychologists often study how the built or physical environment affects human behavior. They may conduct research on this topic, or apply their knowledge to designing safe and ergonomic spaces that are conducive to emotional well-being, such as colorful, open floor plans."

Building appealing work and home-spaces may not save the world, but why isn't it a worthy area of research?

Re:How did we discard the idea of college faculty? by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:33AM (#19513190)
> Note many/most of these excess PhDs are not “researchers” in the pure sciences.

People studying mediaeval literature can also be researchers.

> Such invented pursuits have minimal societal benefit.

I'm sure this is true of some fields, but even fields which produce obvious societal benefits, and even fields which actually do produce PhD candidates who go on to have well-paying jobs in industry often have difficulty growing their departments.