Develop the intuition, then crystallize and formalize the idea with a proof. Otherwise, it's just not going to make any sense.
If you have time, click around on that page and check out some past Euclid (grade 12) math contests. Even if you've come through real analysis I bet some of the later problems in those Euclids will give you trouble.
The end result of months of flailing followed by the "aha" was a grade of C for the class AND being the only one to get a 5 on the AP test.
EDIT: As a fun corollary, I really hated Calculus class in high school. Ironically, I ended up getting a Masters in EE, so I ended up spending the next several years doing Calculus in > 50% of my courses.
EDIT EDIT: Also fun to note was that Calculus was only offered to Seniors at the time and required 4 years of math beforehand: Algebra, Geometry, Advance Math, and Trigonometry. That meant you had to double-up on math in either Sophomore or Junior years, which basically limited class size to a small handful of people.
If so, yeah, we did it that way too, in 11th or 12th grade. (Had the same teacher both years, can't remember when exactly Calc was)
I remember it involving a lot of drawings of graphs so we could understand what each term referred to, and can't really imagine an easier way to learn it.
It is not the way calculus was invented by Newton and Leibniz. They thought in terms of infinitesimals. However, this approach is relatively hard to formalize. It was only done by Robinson in the 1960s.
To see why Cauchy et al had to work on epsilon-delta, take a look at [1], an excellent book.
Same thing at university, in a CS degree. Freshman Calculus taught at a level somewhere between Spivak and Rudin. In fact, both books where on the official course bibliography.
All this took place in a fairly big EU country, ~10 years ago.
"Best" schools (<1%) will have what the article is describing (strong student mathematical problem solving communities lead by teachers with strong mathematical training). Typically very expensive, either directly through tuition or indirectly because they are public schools but only serve students in very high net worth zip codes.
"Very Good" schools (<10%) will include some of the epsilon-delta formalism but might have some curricular problems and a "gifted just means moving through the terrible not-real-math curriculum faster" problem that the article talks about.
"Decent" schools will teach how to compute derivative/integrals by rote and maybe talk a bit about the physical intuitions in a very hand-wavy way. Calculus is very much a continuation of Algebra or Trig where you learn some rules and how to pattern match and don't ask too many questions about why.
The other half of USA high schools? They don't even offer a Calculus course of any kind [1]. Which... if you don't teach it at all, you can't teach it wrong...
As an aside, AP CS has the same problem as the problem identified with AP Calc. AP CS is the epitome of a "Java School" course.
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2016/06/where-...
As a high school student who took AP CS last year, I agree, but in reality the course isn't even about Java. Code is written by hand on the free response portion and Java syntax is mentioned but not really emphasized (things like missing brackets and semicolons are okay on the FRQs). I finished all the questions in about 25 minutes, with over an hour left to twiddle my thumbs.
Even questions about algorithmic analysis (in APCS's case, just sorting algorithms) are done without proper big-O notations, which is just plain stupid IMO.
For a student that has done CS on their own for years now, APCS feels like the fake, industrialized, watered-down version.
If you keep up your self-study, expect further disappointment in most undergrad data structures courses. =P
It's sad they killed it, it looks so fun.
[1]: http://mchs.virtualbeach.com/cs/documents/AP%20Computer%20Sc...
All of the AP tests are roughly comparable in my opinion. Just not too many high school kids are as overprepared for the tests in chemistry, physics, statistics, economics, etc.
That's a bit misleading. There are many districts where one school serves as a magnet school where anyone interested in taking more advanced classes can go. So yes while it may be true that half of all schools don't offer calculus--far less than half of all students can't readily take calculus.
It's news to me that Stuyvesant considers zip code for admissions. I thought it was a standardized test open to all students in the system.
Which focuses on what might be called the calculus approach to mathematical modeling in science/engineering, and uses computer simulations.
Instead, if have some algebra and trigonometry from high school and want to learn calculus, then just get one or a few good freshman COLLEGE calculus books and work through them -- at each lesson or section, read and think about the material and then work all the more challenging exercises. Check answers in the back of the book, a copy of the Instructor's Guide, on the Internet, etc.
For the books, get mostly old ones known for decades to be good. Get just good, used copies -- the subject hasn't changed much in decades. For the books, DO get ones that are good on (A) the completeness property of the real numbers ("Calculus is the elementary consequences of the completeness property of the real numbers."), (B) limits, (C) the epsilon-delta definition of limits, (D) the epsilon-delta, limit definitions of the derivative and the (Riemann) integral, (E) applications. Get more than one such book, use the one that looks the best as your primary source and use the others for alternate explanations and more exercises.
That's what I did: I got a good book and worked through about half of it. Then for calculus in college, I asked to skip freshman calculus and start on sophomore calculus, the rest of the book. A prof gave me a little oral exam, define the derivative, with some TeX notation
f'(x) = d/dx f(x) = lim_{h --> 0} (f(x + h) - f(x))/h
and I was in. I did well, made As both semesters. Went on to advanced calculus, ordinary differential equations, advanced calculus for applications, real analysis, functional analysis, real applications, peer-reviewed publications, teaching calculus, etc. E.g., for an application I derived and used
y'(t) = k y(t) (b - y(t))
to please the BoD at FedEx, keep a crucial investor from leaving, and save FedEx from going out of business.
From what I've seen of high school materials for calculus, I'd advise trying hard to avoid them -- again, just start with one of the best college texts. The one I used for the actual course was Johnson and Kiokmeister, then also used at Harvard, now ancient but still fine.
For young students, a great introductory textbook is Calculus Made Easy. It is around 100 years old, and develops all the material using infinitesimals. Which is essentially modern non-standard analysis, minus rigor. It is also the way Newton and Leibniz thought about calculus, and the way most physicists intuitively think about problems.
For a more mature audience, I like Infinitesimal Calculus by Henle & Kleinberg.