News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook to ban white nationalist content by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @03:56PM (#19505297)
> If Facebook decided to ban all Chinese, Islamic, or African-American content, then the conversation would be completely different.

Also, if they decided to ban all White content, it would be different.

White and White nationalist aren't the same thing; please stop insulting White people that aren't racists by implicitly equating them.

Re:Facebook to ban white nationalist content by justinmchase on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @04:00PM (#19505355)
I don't think he was doing that. He was trying to say that racial discrimination would not be an acceptable reason, I believe. I didn't take it the way you are suggesting at least.
Re:Facebook to ban white nationalist content by sadris on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:46PM (#19506410)
But they're not banning Zionist (Jewish nationalist) content, only White natl content. So they're engaging in illegal discrimination due to disparate impact.
Re:Facebook to ban white nationalist content by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:59PM (#19506558)
> But they're not banning Zionist (Jewish nationalist) content

True.

> So they're engaging in illegal discrimination due to disparate impact.

Disparate impact discrimination is illegal under Title VII (employment) but not Title II (public accommodation), so even assuming FB is covered by Title II (which is dubious), and even assuming this would be found to be disparate impact discrimination (which is difficult to assess because the test for that is narrowly tailored to Title VII context), it would not be illegal on that basis.

Re:Facebook to ban white nationalist content by chubot on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:21PM (#19506740)
Yes, I should have said the "analogous" Chinese, Islamic, or African-American content, e.g. like the sibling suggests with Zionist content.

The thread this spawned reminds me of why I don't usually chime in on these issues. But what many replies are missing is that Facebook says they already ban "white supremacist" content under existing rules. They don't need a special rule for that. Just like they don't need a special rule for terrorist content that's violent.

But they ARE adding a special rule for "white nationalism", for the reasons given in the post.

I'm not saying they are wrong. I'm just saying that you can't really use the argument "they can go set up their own servers" to justify it, as the grandparent did.

I suspect that there's simply a LOT of white nationalist content, and it has a practical damaging effect, but nationalist content of other kinds isn't that widespread or damaging, and they want to allow it for free speech reasons (and probably because they aren't qualified to make fine judgements about various nationalist movements). That seems reasonable.

Anyway, Facebook gives the "right" reason for the ban (a value judgement), while the parent comment was pushing a reason that's besides the point, IMO. It felt like a "backward rationalization". But yeah it's more of a nitpick, so I regret spawning this thread, which became very political :-/

-----

Even so, let me throw something else onto the pile. A few days ago I watched this documentary on Netflix:

Struggle: The Life and Lost Art of Szukalski

https://www.netflix.com/title/80109551

It's too complex to summarize, but it's about a very talented sculptor who was also a Polish nationalist (for a significant period). It came out in December and was produced by Leo DiCaprio, because his father was a friend of the artist in LA.

I googled for reviews afterward, and this was one of the best summaries that I found:

https://www.counter-currents.com/2019/01/a-patriot-without-a...

Only after reading the whole article did I realize that it's from a white nationalist site (if you read "about this site", it's very clear).

The long and short of it is that it's a subtle issue, but most people seem to view it in black and white. If Facebook banned this content, it would be a mistake IMO (although I don't use facebook). But their decision might be the right thing overall. They have a hard job, and people like the parent were trying to apply some strict principle to it, when in reality there's no such thing.