From what I understand when the ETF achieves cash position needed to generate 1 creation unit (usually 50k ETF shares, as you correctly point out), then the fund is absolutely required to purchase underlying shares that index it's tracking requires it to hold. It can't just hold cash and promise to track index nevertheless. Or do you mean that first comes the Creation Unit, and then people can buy shares in ETF?
In case of ETN there's absolutely no obligation to purchase anything, as they're simply debt of issuer; a promise to repay you in the future according to predetermined index or underlying movement.
Maybe you meant ETNs?
P.S. I re-read what you wrote, and I think what you're saying is that large institutions are intermediaries between ETF and investor. That is absolutely correct, and probably is so 99% of the time in the market anyway regardless of whether shares purchased are of individual companies or funds. But ETF is still required to hold the assets it states it will hold, that was my point.
No cash changes hands (unless cash is one of the underlying assets of the ETF), so the ETF is never sitting on cash with the obligation to purchase shares.
In general, it's very unusual to hand cash to an ETF in return for shares (unless cash is one of the underlying assets). I'm not even sure it is legal to do so.
but from investor point of view it still works as I described - she goes to market, places bid for ETF shares. Then the process splits as following:
a) if there are sellers in the market she gets her shares from them b) if there are no sellers, market makers will still sell her the ETF shares
then once market maker accumulates enough cash from buyers, he purchases/borrows shares needed for exchange for N creation units from ETF trust.
I don't think market makers just go and create ETF shares without there first being demand for them?
The ETF will actually never buy the shares. You can only buy existing ETF shares from other traders.
ETF shares are created by large financial institutions - JPM/GS/other big players have the option to make an in-kind trades of share in securities for ETF shares. I.e., if an ETF is 50% MS and 50% AAPL, a large trader can trade 50k shares of AAPL and 50k shares of MS for 100k shares of the ETF. (Similarly, they can perform the reverse trade.)