And a podcast featuring a scholar who's closely followed the development of the system, and whom we interviewed for the article above: https://chinalawandpolicy.com/2018/11/12/whats-the-t-on-chin...
To give you a few examples - [1][2] are news articles discussing the exact same "laolai" list almost 10 years ago.
[1] https://finance.qq.com/a/20101214/004357.htm
[2] http://news.ifeng.com/mainland/detail_2010_10/20/2846252_0.s...
Would not have made this remark about an ordinary commenter but I would expect better from an editor.
My refutations are based on clearly worded, non-ambiguous official documents characterizing court ordered blacklists as part of China's social credit system.
Here's the Chinese Supreme People's Court's website. http://shixin.court.gov.cn/index.html The statement front and center explains that the blacklists are promulgated "to promote the building of a social credit system."
For a more comprehensive look at what China's social credit system is and what its components are, I recommend this site: https://www.chinalawtranslate.com/en/social-credit-documents...
How can this, for example, be considered "China bashing"? > China, undisputed king of electric transport (inkstonenews.com)
15 out of the most recent 30 submissions from your account are China related news, 94% of them are negative. Citing such publicly available stats that can be easily verified by the public is now considered as personal attack? Keep arguing whether 94% or 100% of your submissions are negative doesn't really change anything.
Maybe inkstonenews.com only publish negative China related news articles or you intentionally only submit those negative ones from inkstonenews.com to NH? What is the story here?
I am asking something very simple here - how submitting all negative news adding value to the NH? Are you suggesting that only negative news related to China are considered as newsworthy by you and your site? Or maybe all news come out of China are negative?
The system is claimed to be backed by big data, and sure you can say there is no numerical score but come on.
The video discussed below goes into this in detail, discussing what does exist, what experiments there are, and where the researcher thinks China is heading.
The social credit score system is an actual scoring system based on your overall social activities, including both financial and non-financial (e.g. the rightfully dreaded political/religious activity). No nobody knows exactly how it works and no one I know in China actually knows their score or anything even qualitative about their score.
The discredited list is just a yes or no list based on court judgement for your financial debt, nothing more and nothing less. It is a public list and there is a clear way to end up on it.