Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform
by swebs on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:56AM
(#19492976)
I like the idea of referendums. It shows how much people care about important issues. Internet polls are useless since they can be cheated and petitions suck because they don't measure how many people are opposed to the petition.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform
by magduf on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @03:31PM
(#19495246)
Referenda only work when the populace is informed and educated enough to make good decisions. Otherwise, you get Brexit.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform
by stordoff on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @06:48PM
(#19496668)
_Only_ if they are adequately defined (and it's clear what the legal effect is). Two and a half years on from the Brexit referendum, we are still arguing about what it even _means_, and it's not clear if people even want to leave anymore. Ideally, they should be considered advisory only, otherwise you could end up with a tyranny of the majority situation (a very slight majority is probably not a good reason to make sweeping changes), or at least require a supermajority. I'd also say that in a lot of cases people do not understand the implications of what they are voting for, hence my preference for electing a representative to make these decisions, who are at least in theory elected to consider this effects.