You had "Chicago style" economists yelling at the government to dismantle Fanny and Freddie for years before the collapse, those shining examples of government long-term economic planning. For decades free market economists advocated replacing the Federal Reserves short-term focus on quarterly GDP with a mandate to maintain long-term price stability. Oh, and they have been railing against both parties for racking up such a huge public debt.
Then when the shit hits the fan, all people remember is a caricature of "Chicago-style" economists, not what they actually said and did.
The narrative that the United States lost its way through too much deregulation and free market fundamentalism is cheap rhetoric that doesn't become any more true the more often it is repeated. It is symptomatic of too much education by the way of opinion articles.
In contrast to the UK, which went the other direction after the war and nationalised and socialised so much that it's economy was moribund by the 1970's, in complete isolation with the emerging powerhouse that was the West German economy.
Sure, the Germans have had a problem with unemployment, and youth unemployment in particular, but they enjoy a high standard of living and a stable and prosperous economy. And the unemployment rate has been dropping since the conservative-minded government has been in power. It is now lower than most US states.
So I would contend that Germany, particularly throughout the period from 1950-1980 was following a classical liberal economic philosophy more closely than just about any other Western country, the US included. And the results showed. Though I would say it was more Austrian school based than Chicago.
I also don't agree with your assertion that socialism is required to keep an industry going. For that you just need an export-led manufacturing sector, good technical training in schools, and to keep the finance sector in it's place, instead of being allowed to dominate the economy and thus wield political power.
Interestingly enough, the Germans haven't had a housing crash because there was no housing boom. And that's because there was no attempt to change the ownership levels amongst people who didn't own a home.
Trade barriers
WTF?! Trade barriers are very, very bad for industrial economies.
Also, I think the case for subsidies is arguable at best. Subsidies may be useful in emerging market sectors, but are usually better structured as public spending on research etc. (Obviously argument this doesn't apply to health care any more than it does to other areas of public good such as roads, police, defense etc)
Governing a nation is like cooking a small fish, grasshopper. A little bit of salt (subsidies, tariffs, regulation, taxation to pay for infrastructure, etc) is a wonderful thing, too much salt is unfortunately very easy to apply. And arguments about whether salt "is good" or "is bad" are just plain silly and show that you haven't cooked that many fish.
Not really.
You hurt your own economy because your own consumers now to pay a higher price for their goods. The protected manufacturer has reduced incentive to reduce costs or improve quality. And of course you have hurt people on the other side of the world, who also happen to be humans with families and aspirations, by cutting them out of your market.
The only winners from trade barriers are the protected. Everyone else loses, over and above the ostensible benefits.
> Not really.
Yes really, though not always. (The word "only" when talking about who benefits is a little to coarse a generalization...) The tradeoff is between cheap goods now and capitalization (building of factories, etc) for later; often, without tariffs, the local industry would never even be able to get off the ground to where it is competitive. And if "the protected" contribute to the overall economy (a big if, I grant) then the country as a whole benefits. It is how the US did, how Japan did/ does it, sort of how China does it, etc, etc. And you are right that too much protection can make industries less competitive ... except when it doesn't... Like all tradeoffs, there are tradeoffs.
The complexity of human society defies abstract reasoning, and begs for actual example. I don't see any grounding in actual knowledge of history in your arguments (though (1) I grant that too much protectionism is just as bad as too little, and (2) you are probably better grounded in fact than your arguments).
Even that is dangerous because of the tendency of the emerging industry to rely on them.
An alternate model is that followed by Thailand and its car industry. The Thais aggressively pushed for and signed unilateral free trade agreements with a number of post-industrial and industrial economies and then leveraged those trade agreements as a tool to encourage large investments in heavy industry.
The fact that cars imported from Thailand attract no import duty in a large number of countries has made them a very attractive investment target for companies like Honda who have since built factories there.
The complexity of human society is an argument in favour of freer markets. Knowledge about resources and demands is distributed extremely widely and no one actor can gather and react to even a miniscule fraction of it, compared to the totality.
Protectionism, amongst other things, is an act of central planning. Those who decide what to protect and what to leave open are making guesses about the current and future economy which might or might not be true. Given the poor record of central planning in every form it has been tried (most famously Gosplan), I would prefer to let a distributed dynamic optimising system create an approximate solution to an incomplete-knowledge problem than to wait for a single actor provide a perfect single solution.
For an example of a shock that exposes these problems in the U.S./China trade, if oil prices rise, everyone loses. The producers will have to absorb higher export costs by raising prices. Subsequently, sales fall. Recession on both sides.
Trade barriers are a way to encourage local production, which will not only diversify the economy, but insulate against resource shocks. The problem isn't in raising them, but in lowering them later on when the market needs more efficiency; at that point, the fat incumbents will lobby hard to keep their protection.
See, for the classic example, Japan's MITI. An uninterrupted story of the brightest men and women in Japan making incorrect guess after faulty prediciton, leavened with a dose of no-better-than-random-chance blockbuster industrial picks.