News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by turbinerneiter on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:12AM (#19490986)
Literally nobody is doing that.

Young EU supporters, like me, are the very people who were demonstrating against this.

We are caught between reckless Brexiteering nationalists and a lobby-bought EU parliament.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by vsl on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @09:04AM (#19491379)
Maybe this will have you reflect on dismissing opposition to EU ("reckless Brexiteering nationalists") and consider why people may oppose (some aspects of) current EU. Some of those "reckless Brexiteering nationalists" may simply have experienced similar things with EU legislation before, in areas you don't care about.

I wouldn't say this is about "lobby-bought EU parliament". This is about the parliament routinely rubber-stamping everything. Rejections are extremely rare. This legislation had so wide opposition that there was a chance it won't pass. Even this passed. Consider how well the process works for things that aren't of so much public interest.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by trkh0 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:17AM (#19491011)
There is no denying that postings here get hijacked by those who praise every fine and law directed at american tech companies so they should know or admit it if they do that this "directive" is part of that trend.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by andrepd on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:21AM (#19491041)
So what you're saying is that some people support some measures (while others don't) and disagree strongly with others (while some do agree). Sounds... right? :p
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by sadris on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:16AM (#19491008)
Maybe you should have sided with the nationalists all along?
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by js8 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:23AM (#19491057)
Thanks but no. There are alternatives, such as diem25.org.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:14AM (#19491000)
Perhaps if you see EU parliament as "lobby-bought", you can accept there is good reason to oppose the EU, and stop calling brexiteers "nationalists".
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by icebraining on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:23AM (#19491060)
Except local parliaments are also lobby-bought, so that doesn't solve the problem. Brexit is the politician's fallacy in action.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by prepend on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:41AM (#19491195)
This is an interesting problem to me. I sometimes think that having multiple locally bought lobbies with individual priorities is preferred to a single giant lobby doing winner take all on large scales.

It’s pessimistic as it assumes always corruption. But pragmatic as it minimizes corruption by maximiing the inefficiency and cost necessary for lobbies to spread cash more thinly and come into conflict with lobby arbitrage country by country. For example, copyright lobby might win in country #1, but hardware lobby wins in country #2 and we end up with conflicting laws in different countries. As opposed to both countries using the same laws so it comes down to which country spends the most money in total gets their law in both countries.

Of course, I think it would be better to have a law set that represents will of the people and Pareto frontier of max indicidual benefit and community benefit.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by icebraining on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @09:45AM (#19491721)
But you have giant lobbies anyway, because companies and cartels are multinational, even if the parliaments aren't.

We already have three major international copyright treaties (Berne, UCC and TRIPS), two of which actually predate the EU, and the other was not primarily pushed by it, which set strict rules on how "independent" parliaments can legislate. So not having the EU doesn't seem to have helped.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:43AM (#19491226)
Solve what problem? The problem of lobbies in general? No, it doesn't.

The problem of EU lobbying, and inter-national divide-and-conquer? Yes, to some extent.

Framing this as politician's fallacy, action for the sake of action, suggests that lobbying won't be worse in the EU than at a local level. In reality, it's easier to consolidate a smaller same-nation population, than multiple international ones. Just look at how stereotypes are used to discredit - lazy greeks, racist little-englanders etc.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by icebraining on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:58AM (#19491333)
That suggests further splitting up the UK would also improve the political situation; do you support such a proposal?
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:02PM (#19493039)
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by icebraining on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @03:58PM (#19495454)
That's not exactly spliting up the UK.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @07:19PM (#19496828)
Then you'd have to tell me what kind of action my comments imply. Opposing consolidation of power over multiple populations who can only oppose it in aggregate is what I imply is bad, and discord / lack of unity among those populations gives umbalanced influence to that unified central power.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by sisu2019 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @09:16AM (#19491467)
Local parliaments are closer and have more contact with their constituents so they'll automatically be more transparent and if my local government becomes unbearable I can move 200 KM and be free of it but if the EU becomes unbearable I have to move 2000+ KMs to a new continent.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by barrkel on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:17AM (#19491014)
There are no polls left showing support for Leave, and still parliament is pursuing it. Good reason to leave UK.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:38AM (#19491170)
There was a referendum, who cares what the polls say.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by cr1895 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:52AM (#19491283)
What was the referendum beyond a large-scale poll? It wasn't binding in nature.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Chris2048 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:02PM (#19493042)
Very well:

There was a large-scale poll, who cares what the small-scale polls say.

Of course, referendums aren't really polls. Polls have no official effect, you can freely refuse them and lose nothing.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by FabHK on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:15AM (#19491005)
Well, it's a damn shame, a lamentable mistake. Maybe it is even indicative of structural issues. (Having said that, the EU is still one of my favourite jurisdictions to be based in. And there are not many people that extol "everything the EU does"; things are rarely black and white.)
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by coffeeaddicted on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:32AM (#19491129)
It's the biggest blow the EU has given me so far. And yes, my support for the EU got weakened a lot by this. Just... the guys voting for this law had generally been the converative and more nationalistic parties which usually argue against the EU.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:13AM (#19490993)
Well, my position has been that platforms have been built on the knowledge that they're heavily used for content theft but that they're shielded from liability for it unfairly. (See Section 230 here in the US). And I think the tech industry is a pox on our news media and the money they need to do real investigative work. (See Apple taking like a solid 50% revenue on their news service.)

I'm reasonably happy the EU is interested in shifting profits back away from big tech, and confident the Internet will adjust and survive the reduced viability of the large content platforms.

As a fan of decentralization and quality journalism, and no ties to any company affected positively or negatively by these decisions, I'm on board.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:23AM (#19491058)
> platforms have been built on the knowledge that they're heavily used for content theft

Yes, and most providers have usually done a good job at reducing content theft on their platforms, to the extent of their capabilities.

The only thing that has changed is that now they can be punished for not meeting someone elses subjective standard.

> I'm reasonably happy the EU is interested in shifting profits back away from big tech

If that's what you believe, then I understand your position. Sadly, you could very well be completely mistaken. Google, Facebook & Co. already have their filters; they can prove that they're trying their best.

It's only the smaller communities that will be affected, and they won't have the money for dozens of well-paid machine-learning specialists to build them content filters. We'll see how long it takes for google to sell access to their services.

Of course, if you think I'm mistaken, I'd love to hear your reasoning (I'd also really love to be proven wrong on this topic)

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:35AM (#19491152)
Machine learning based moderation has time and time again proven to be woefully inadequate. Human intervention is required, and Content ID does not meet the requirements of this new article. And I would argue the amount of cash Google and Facebook stockpile rather than hiring human moderators reflects that they are doing far from "their best".

Platforms that have human reviewed content or where people self-host their own content will have no issues with this change, and platforms will be likely significantly less profitable if they truly move to comply with the law, as it will require armies of humans, or massive liability costs.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by cotelletta on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:22AM (#19491047)
There is no way this new law actually protects little guys. All the exemptions for small platforms go away once that platform exists for 3 years. After that you turn into another Google and Facebook. So is the EU somehow expecting a new market to open up for alternative players who only expect to be around for 3 years, before closing up shop? Who is going to invest in that? How is it going to make "big tech" less powerful when it is explicitly an on-ramp to bait and switch more "big tech" into existence?

The directive is idiotic, self contradictory, and cannot possibly do what they say it will.

It is stunning that critical thinking is now so bad that they can convince a majority of MEPs this is not a complete fantasy.

RIP EU. This is the last straw. Selling off free expression for cheap Russian gas. Motherfuckers. If I hear one more "muh russian internet manipulation" peep from these twats...

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:31AM (#19491121)
> It is stunning that critical thinking is now so bad that they can convince a majority of MEPs this is not a complete fantasy.

I don't think MEPs are dumb or incompetent for anything other than choosing the wrong people to advise them on technical issues. Consider that not everyone necessarily understands how internet content even works.

Politicians don't even seem to understand that you can't "just scan content that infringes on copyright"; that you have to scan the content precisely to find out if it does so.

What worries me is how they don't admit that they don't understand the situation. That they blindly believe that they can get a rough understanding of things and create good laws easily.

What worries me even more is how they ignored the clear protest from large parts of the population and just powered through it as fast as they could. It's the same as with GDPR; they only hurt the small guys because they don't understand what they're even making the law for.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by cotelletta on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:43AM (#19491217)
If they don't have basic digital literacy, they are not qualified to be a politician in the 21st century. It's the same old story.

I'm not "worried", I want these people out of office and far away from influence. The B Ark is in charge.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by sisu2019 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @09:20AM (#19491494)
> I'm reasonably happy the EU is interested in shifting profits back away from big tech

This is not going to happen. Regulations are very likely to favor incumbents as their high rate of profit can more easily accommodate them. Incidentally this is the reason why sometimes big companies are in favor of laws that seem to be bad for them: they are worse for the competition.

[dead]
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:33AM (#19491138)
Hey, I hate google almost as much as people who eat while on the computer, but I still think this law is dumb. Many have already pointed out how it actually plays directly into the hands of Google and other big tech.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:51AM (#19491280)
I don't understand this view at all. Why would a company that benefits this law spend so much money trying to prevent it from passing? Surely by now we recognize that big tech will always move in the direction of its own profits, so shouldn't we look at what they're aiming for, and recognize that is their best case scenario?

I would argue that the people who make policy decisions at Google are incredibly smart. If this was going to cement their monopoly, wouldn't their resistance to it be... Muted at best?

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by tomhoward on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @09:39AM (#19491666)
> I don't understand this view at all. Why would a company that benefits this law spend so much money trying to prevent it from passing?

A couple of Devil's Advocate suggestions for you:

- Their self-interest is enlightened enough to see that there is long-term benefit in the playing field being at least somewhat even, e.g., because unassailable monopolies become lazy and eventually collapse under their own weight.

- The people who run Google were startup founders once, and many of their employees and products were once startup founders/startups, so they know that a healthy startup ecosystem is to their benefit.

I neither strongly believe nor disbelieve the truth of these positions. Nor do I know if they are any part of Google’s thinking behind its campaigning.

I'm just suggesting them as possibilities that might help you make your own position more robust.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by raverbashing on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:13AM (#19490990)
funny how it's always a throwaway...

But yeah nobody is defending this unless you're part of the copyright lobby, the news lobby or some other mafia-like organization

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by tomtompl on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:49AM (#19491261)
Sounds quite sad in the context of this being passed by EU bodies, and really by those for whom no one ever even voted.