News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by stcredzero on Monday March 25, 2019 @06:11PM (#19487206)
The Internet is optimized for throughput at lowest cost.

No amount of good netcode that you write can compensate for this.

The problem is the internet itself.

The internet doesn’t care about your game.

The Internet did change, such that streaming movies became viable. Given that games are now bigger than movies, could it be argued that that the network lag we're seeing is the industry lagging behind the culture? (Which it generally does, at least a little.)

A part of this might well involve special deals between large companies involving specialized infrastructure. There are such things now involved with movie streaming. Google's plans involve the infrastructure part of that already. What happens to net neutrality?

Once game streaming becomes mature, then it's only a matter of time for App streaming to follow. We'll be back in the mainframe days, just with much larger companies with much larger multi-box cloud "mainframes", commanding the attention of a much larger portion of the population and the culture. "The computer is your friend. Trust the computer!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paranoia_(role-playing_game)

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by politician on Monday March 25, 2019 @06:32PM (#19487360)
> What happens to net neutrality?

Counterintuitively, the market that Network Next is making shifts us closer to actual net neutrality than relying on the benevolence of FCC or Comcast by putting power into the hands of content providers where previously they were at the mercy of last-mile ISPs.

If businesses can collectively bid for performance from private networks to offset actions by last-mile ISPs to cut costs and reduce service, then they also have the power to organize a general strike by refusing to bid for performance from traffic from specific ISPs until they work out better rates throughout the value chain.

So I see this as a mechanism to restore the spirit of net neutrality despite the best wishes of the FCC.

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by mrosett on Monday March 25, 2019 @07:59PM (#19487966)
> If businesses can collectively bid for performance from private networks

You realize this is exactly what net neutrality prohibits?

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by gafferongames on Monday March 25, 2019 @08:53PM (#19488265)
Network neutrality does not apply to private networks. But even so, we care deeply about network neutrality. We are creating a truly neutral marketplace where suppliers cannot act in an anti-competitive manner towards buyers, and can only compete on performance and price.

To the poster who said that we are trying to restore the true spirit of network neutrality. Bravo, you get it. This is exactly what we intend to do.

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by fulafel on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:18AM (#19489641)
To add to the bandwidth characerisation:

Bandwidth has followed an improvement curve since the early days of the internet, though it has slowed down a lot lately.

Streaming movies became viable despite the slowing rate of bandwidth improvement. We had 30 kbps modems in the 90s, then 8 Mbit ADSL1 in 1998, 24 MBit ADSL 2+ in 2003s, 40 MBit DOCSIS around the same times. If the speeds had continued to improve at the same exponential curve, consumers would have 100+ gig broadband by now.

The same is true about datacenters, the bandwidth per compute capacity available to servers has decreased for a while.

Bandwidth is an easier problem than latency, because it's not limited by speed of light.

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by milesward on Monday March 25, 2019 @10:00PM (#19488656)
Wanna build your game on the same network Stadia uses? Https://cloud.google.com
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by Matheus28 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:41PM (#19494185)
And pay an obscenely high amount of money for bandwidth? Those providers all charge at least $0.05/GB; you can get bandwidth for a tenth of that elsewhere. Games use a lot of bandwidth at scale (agar.io would use a couple of PB a month). For F2P games, server costs eat a lot of revenue if you use those premium providers.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by tree123 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:22AM (#19510819)
Why did you stop making io games? Where did you learn multiplayer game development?
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by gafferongames on Monday March 25, 2019 @10:25PM (#19488784)
Believe it or not, even the routing to google data centers can be improved.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by ucaetano on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:48AM (#19489373)
Not to the datacenters, just to the POPs or edge nodes, after that, it is all private networks. And, afaik, the distance to the closest pop or edge node is a small share of the total distance to the datacenters.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by gafferongames on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:11PM (#19493137)
We are measuring improvement to google’s own data centers.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by ucaetano on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:28PM (#19493295)
No, you're measuring improvement to the POP where you peer with Google.

Unless you're telling me that Google is giving you access to its private networks all the way to the datacenters, which I'd find hard to believe.

Between you and a Google Datacenter, most of the path is through Google's private networks.

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by gafferongames on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:34PM (#19493379)
We are measuring significant latency reductions for real players to google data centers right now. You seem to be overestimating how perfectly anycast finds the best PoP to get on the private network. You also assume that google’s private network is optimal from every point on the USA to their own data centers. This is not true. What’s better that google’s network? Everybody else’s, and google’s network, evaluated once every 10 seconds.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by gafferongames on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:50PM (#19493555)
Ucetano: I’ve already explained why you’re wrong, but you don’t understand it. I’m not here to argue with you.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by ucaetano on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:06PM (#19493753)
You didn't, you just hand-waved and threw some claims around without any data to back it up, and you didn't address the key issue: you don't have access to datacenters, only to POPs.
Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by ucaetano on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:44PM (#19493496)
> We are measuring significant latency reductions for real players to google data centers right now.

Again, you only have visibility to the POPs, so you're only seeing improvements on the path to the POP.

For example: there is no Google POP anywhere near its Oregon datacenter[1]. You literally can't just push your traffic to the Dalles and plug into the datacenter.

So, no matter where your customer is, you can only improve the traffic to the Seattle or the Bay Area POPs, where the traffic will move over to Google's private network.

Sorry, but I have to call BS on your claims...

[1] https://peering.google.com/#/infrastructure

Re:Fixing the Internet for Games by supermatt on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:37PM (#19494751)
As I understood it, they are measuring the latency to game servers located in googles datacenter. This is why they are talking about that. They cant measure game latency to a PoP, because the game server isn't at the PoP.

Instead of routing to the nearest PoP, they route to the PoP that provides the lowest latency to their game server. I don't understand the confusion. They are simply measuring latency over a number of different routes and choosing the optimal one (for their use case).

Maybe you are assuming that there is no latency between the PoPs and the datacentres? I can assure you thats not the case.