As far as the broader configurability questions, it's not so much that I want options libinput doesn't have (though that's a little bit of it).
It's more that I want the default behavior to be good enough where accessing the options aren't necessary (e.g., Macbook). In the event that the default options aren't that good, I want visual settings to tune the experience. Gnome 3 with libinput currently provides two options. Neither is pointer acceleration.
Since much of what I hope to improve the "feel" of default behavior, I don't think this could be as straightforward as "submit a PR to libinput." I think it could end up being a lot of work to get the default experience feeling great. The number of folks with interest in this esoteric subject seems to me like evidence of that.
The purpose of the fork cannot be just to provide sane defaults.
Pretty sure that's what the libinput developers want, too.
You gave up on libinput after an inability to configure scroll speed, but the rest of those are all configurable with libinput and libinput-gestures[1].
I don't use gestures yet and default scroll speed has always been fine, and the following tiny libinput configuration hits the rest of your points.
Is there a reason you haven't asked the libinput maintainer about whether configurable scroll speed would be welcome upstream (in the prior post, it comes across like your question was far more open ended)? Forking it just to add scroll speed configuration and replicate work that's already been done elsewhere seems a little excessive.[1] https://github.com/bulletmark/libinput-gestures