News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by jaysonelliot on Sunday November 28, 2010 @04:58PM (#1948456)
I often forget how much we take for granted our right to free speech in America, until I read a story from a country that doesn't have the same constitutional protections.
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by StavrosK on Sunday November 28, 2010 @05:35PM (#1948556)
This is tangential, but I only appreciated Greek airtravel when I had a TSA agent grope me when entering the US. In my case, I actually experienced your lack of constitutional protections (or constitution in general, in airports), and I have another such experience to look forward to when leaving.
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by jaysonelliot on Sunday November 28, 2010 @06:03PM (#1948653)
The trouble with our constitutional protections is that they only mean something when we stand up to enforce them.

There's been an awful lot of trampling on the Constitution in the past decade or so.

Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by StavrosK on Sunday November 28, 2010 @06:06PM (#1948667)
Well, for what it's worth, I'm standing up by objecting to the strip machines at least.
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by tst_ on Sunday November 28, 2010 @05:09PM (#1948485)
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by tptacek on Sunday November 28, 2010 @05:24PM (#1948529)
Not remotely comparable. In the story you linked to, assets linked to specific crimes committed in the US were seized using civil forfeiture rules (if they were in fact seized; see: stories suggesting this is a hoax). The owners of those domains received court orders and have ample due process protections.

Ordinary citizens linking to those sites or to the new versions of those sites sure to be launched shortly aren't touched at all by these actions; the goal being to shut down ongoing criminal enterprises and not to stifle speech.

Read analyses of the State Department Counsel's letter to Wikileaks to see that the government has had to stop short of even calling Wikileaks itself a criminal actor (the leak itself of those documents to WL being prima facie a crime, but not one WL has liability for). The largest media companies in the United States are publishing the contents of those documents, for profit, with virtually no legal exposure.

Sorry. Australia sucks, at least on this axis.

Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by chc on Sunday November 28, 2010 @05:28PM (#1948540)
Some of those "criminal enterprises" were criminal only because they distributed data the US government said should not be distributed. WikiLeaks distributes data the Australian government has decided shouldn't be distributed. It sounds a little bit comparable to me, even if you agree that one kind of data should be allowed and the other shouldn't.
Re:Australia blocks access to Wikileaks, $11K/day fine for l... by tptacek on Sunday November 28, 2010 @05:57PM (#1948632)
No, they were criminal enterprises because they violated multiple decades-old statutes in the US code. Moreover, speech (or links to speech) weren't restricted; only assets belonging to enterprises accused of copyright violations.

And, again, the sites weren't simply "blacklisted", but rather had their assets sued for and seized in an actual civil action.