Re:Ruby is beautiful (but I'm moving to Python)
by cdavid on Sunday November 28, 2010 @09:17PM
(#1949119)
Actually, there is fragmentation: pip does not supersedes easy_install, since easy_install does things that pip cannot do (like installing from something that is not a source tarball). Also, distribute being a fork of setuptools, with neither distribute/setuptools being a superset of each other, means more fragmentation as well.
Also, the affirmation that everything install fine whether you use setuptools/distribute/distutils is simply not true. We get almost daily bug reports/user complaints in numpy/scipy because of installation issues mostly caused by distutils, or people using pip/easy_install (which does not work with numpy distutils extensions). The situation is confusing for a lot of users, especially the ones who are not super familiar with python.
There's really no fragmentation whatsoever that I've seen. Install a package using your preferred way, in the end everything installs fine whether it's built with setuptools, distutils or distribute (or just copy the files to your site-packages directory). I haven't read the entire blog post yet, so I haven't gotten to the part you quote, but that's my two cents.