Re:M-16: A Bureaucratic Horror Story (1981)
by potta_coffee on Monday March 25, 2019 @01:39PM
(#19484647)
I've personally had rifles fail after firing thousands of rounds, which can happen in a surprisingly short period of time.
Re:M-16: A Bureaucratic Horror Story (1981)
by int_19h on Monday March 25, 2019 @06:56PM
(#19487545)
I'm not surprised - obviously, the longer you go, the higher percentage of them will fail, and that's true for AK and others just as much. I'm specifically addressing the myth that because of the Stoner action depositing more carbon inside the receiver, you must clean AR much more often than other assault rifles, and that it will fail quickly if you do not.
So these experiments show that carbon accumulation is not the issue. There are other things about AR design that make it less reliable in some cases (and more reliable in others, like that infamous mud test), but they apply to both DI and piston ARs.
Not using a piston has two advantages. First, it's lighter in general, and in particular, there's less reciprocating mass, which means that weapon is easier to control, especially in full auto. Second, the recoil impulse in Stoner's design goes directly back along the bore axis (which is why it doesn't have carrier tilt!), whereas pistons add an angular component, which translates to more muzzle flip.
The disadvantage is that you get carbon deposits in the action. But the effect is usually overstated - there were numerous tests with uncleaned ARs firing several thousand rounds without any ill effects from the carbon - it just keeps running so long as you keep lubricating it. According to Armalite, most of the deposits are in places where they don't matter, and where they do matter, the action itself is designed to remove much of them as it cycles.