Basically, if "close-ish" is acceptable, then a numeric input makes a ton of sense. And that's the case for lots of things, and most of those things wouldn't be entered with a keyboard (unless you want to get the figure in the ballpark).
If the number is <10 or so most of the time, then a menu makes a ton of sense (number of socks), and include a "custom" option so users can enter their own numbers. I do this with all kinds of things that only need a ballpark number but don't benefit from tweaking (e.g. seconds in an internal; basically, if 10 options or so makes sense, just make it a menu).
I happen to work with graphical things that don't need to be precise much of the time but need more precision that a set of presets. But most retail and whatnot apps are not that.
I agree with that, but this is an attribute of a text entry field. Like I said, we already have a different widget that accommodates the "I don't care what the value is, but I want to be able to easily fudge it upwards or downwards" use case.
Also, input does not necessarily mean text entry. We have <input type=“checkbox”/> and <input type=“button”/> among others.
Some people do like spin boxes, and they allow you to adjust numeric values without reaching for the digit row on your keyboard. By all means, don’t use them if you don’t like them, but they do exist for a reason.
Whether spinboxes are good UI is a separate debate.
If I'm not mistaken, using type="pattern" also means I can't use min or max.
A spinbox only makes sense if you don't care what the value is, such that any two nearby values are exactly equivalent. And that is what the W3 guidance you quote says:
> Getting a credit card number wrong by 1 in the last digit isn’t a minor mistake, it’s as wrong as getting every digit incorrect. [And that's why a card number field should not use a spinbox.]
This suggests to me that the real problem is the idea that "type=numeric" means you want a spinbox. You don't ever want a spinbox; there's no reason for any attribute to give you one. But you frequently do want to restrict the input to numeric characters.
Mouse-adjustable low-resolution analog values have their own widget, the scrollbar. If you somehow find yourself wishing for a spinbox, use one of those.