Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by CalChris on Sunday March 24, 2019 @02:45PM
(#19478002)
This is similar to the C preprocessor trick STRINGIZE:
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by gpderetta on Sunday March 24, 2019 @03:23PM
(#19478218)
It probably uses stringification under the hood, but then relies on constexpr to "canonicalize" the name (removing everything before the dot, template parameters etc).
From cursory reading, it seems it doesn’t, at all. It uses compiler-specific predefined values __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ (gcc, clang) or __FUNCSIG__ (MS Visual C++), and doesn’t work on other compilers.
It also has to do work to extract the function name from the char arrays/C strings that those macros expand to.
Reading answers to https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4384765/whats-the-differ..., it seems it would have been easier to use the __FUNCTION__ in gcc, but I’m not familiar with that (or the other predefined values) at all, so who knows?
Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by anon4242 on Sunday March 24, 2019 @04:54PM
(#19478708)
Actually, __FUNCTION__ won't work as it only expands to the name of the function, not any templates or arguments.
It's actually a pretty clever way to automagically deduce not only names of variables but also of enums :). Too bad it's most likely not maintainable in the long run as compilers probably change what their __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ (or equivalent) macros expand to in new versions.
I usually check the newest versions of compilers, and if the behavior changes, then I update the code
Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by asveikau on Sunday March 24, 2019 @05:05PM
(#19478780)
Last I knew __FUNCTION__ in GCC doesn't even do name de-mangling. You'd get the raw C symbol name with no C++ types.
Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by asveikau on Monday March 25, 2019 @10:15AM
(#19482527)
Gcc 7. I could be wrong but I seem to recall a long time ago, when I was learning this stuff in the 90s, __FUNCTION__ wouldn't even demangle.
yeap, I use __PRETTY_FUNCTION__.
You are absolutely right :)
Re:Show HN: Nameof Operator for Modern C++
by asveikau on Sunday March 24, 2019 @05:03PM
(#19478765)
That was what I was thinking, then I saw that this will stringify enum values, eg. nameof(c) returns "RED", which the preprocessor #x will not do.
To be sure:
nameof(c) returns "c" (nameof return name of variable)
nameof_enum(c) returns "RED" (nameof_enum return enum name of enum variable)