Polyfilling WebP support just for browsers that support Web Assembly but not WebP seems pretty weighty when it's very straightforward to not exclusively use WebP.
The <picture> element is great but using it means not, as you wrote, "Use WebP! For everything!" Maybe you meant "Use WebP! For everything! With Fallbacks!"
> "Use WebP! For everything! With Fallbacks!"
I can get behind that. :-)
What I meant by "for everything" was to use it for both photographic images and illustrations instead of using two different formats.
In addition, all modern browsers support the <picture> element, which allows them to automatically download image the best meets their needs.