Re:Homosexuality in giraffes and other non-human animals
by d0mine on Sunday March 24, 2019 @12:36AM
(#19474343)
> "science open to revision"
It doesn't mean that you can't make statements that are always true (today, tomorrow, in a hundred years, etc).
Once something is discovered and we understand the limits of the model, it is true forever e.g., Newton's laws under appropriate assumptions (not too fast, not much mass).
Re:Homosexuality in giraffes and other non-human animals
by majewsky on Sunday March 24, 2019 @03:18PM
(#19478184)
Yeah, but most social sciences are nowhere near the standards that physics imposes on what it holds to be true.
That's not a flack. It's inherent to the nature of the social sciences. Since every individual is part of a complex social system, it's incredibly hard to make repeatable experiments to test assumptions in the same way that physicists do every day for breakfast.
Re:Homosexuality in giraffes and other non-human animals
by d0mine on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:01PM
(#19503015)
It doesn't matter how complex a studied phenomenon; if proper methods are not used, it is not science.
Both astrology and astronomy can study the same stars -- the difference is in methods they use (and only one is science).
If in ten years, this research into animal sexuality was show to be falsified, misinterpreted, or just not representative of a wide range of nature, would you then decide human homosexuality is morally wrong?
That's the real risk of taking something which should be more of a moral axiom and claiming it derives from science and nature; you risk having it overturned in the future.