If you continue to troll HN we will ban you. Please stop posting unsubstantive comments as well.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Oh shut up and let people disagree you fucking insane sjw.

Now wait just a moment - isn't pointing out things are "too white" exactly analogous? Yet that's somehow acceptable to say at almost any major media outlet [1]. You yourself implied his comment would have been okay if directed at Christians. Why should white people be the only group that's called out for over-representation?

[1] E.g. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/29/eu-is-too-whit...

Agreed. It's not right to single out any religion, particularly insomuch as some flavor of this insularity can be found in every stream of religious thought that has ever existed

Generally, I have low tolerance for any group that segregates most of their existence from the greater whole - but then demands accommodation from the greater whole. Most Jews, Christians and Muslims do not - but some do - those communities who refuse to participate in broader society are in my mind inherently forfeiting their place at the table - simply put, you cannot expect broader society to accommodate your particular needs if you don't participate in it.

Calling out anti-semites or their methods is not echoing anti-semitism. I've edited the actual parens out but I'm not deleting the comment. People are free to flag it if they disagree.

I agree with you. Calling out anti-semitic speech as "that's not OK here, even if you first flash it overtly and then make it slightly less obvious" seems to me to be the exact opposite of that accusation.