Hello, Community Advocate from GitLab here.
We are an open core company. We ship two editions - Community Edition and Enterprise Edition. CE is completely open source and licensed under MIT license. EE is proprietary, closed source code but we try to work in a way similar to GitLab CE: the issue tracker is publicly viewable and the EE license allows modifications.
In conclusion (TLDR), GitLab has an open core business model and ships both open and closed source software.
> GitHub is not FOSS. Gitlab is.
Firstly, I don't think it is hypocritical to run a service that isn't FOSS, but that also supports FOSS. Secondly, nobody is under the illusion that Github is open source. Thirdly, Gitlab is only partly open source. Many of its features aren't.
> Github pull requests suck, why not just use email?
Maybe because email doesn't: a) Give you a convenient list of open pull requests, b) Give you a list of pull requests that other people can see at all c) Let you do nice line-by-line code reviews, d) Let you integrate CI tools easily, etc. etc. etc.
> You can't host malware on Github
Ok?
> I set up gitolite for repository access control, cgit for a simple Web frontend, and I plan to include an issue tracker that treats E-mail as first-class rather than forcing users to create accounts (possibly Bugzilla but I'm open to suggestions)
Riiiight. I'm sure everyone will love going back to the good old days of Bugzilla.