Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions
by pedrocr on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:34AM
(#19469768)
> There can be quite reasonable use cases for that information
What reasonable use case is there for a detection of the test cycle just from ECU information? If you're just testing stuff surely you have access to the ECU to just set a flag manually for anything you need?
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions
by _ph_ on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:45AM
(#19469804)
Could be reasonabe safety features like not performing emergency breaking, or functions aiding the testing process (without interfering with it of course).
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions
by pedrocr on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:40AM
(#19470882)
I can see plenty of reasons to change behavior for the test. But that's not the question. The question is why infer you are being tested through the ECU inputs? Setting a flag manually seems like a much better solution for all those objectives versus a possibly unreliable inference from speed and other data.
As the article writes, there are other "strange" engine configurations with other car manufacturers, like using the outside temperature. Reducing or switching off the exhaust cleaning system at outside temperatures below 17C (the tests are guaranteed to be done at 20C) achieves a similar effect to what VW was doing without literally breaking the law by using a defeat device.