News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by TheRealDunkirk on Friday March 22, 2019 @10:27PM (#19468679)
I work in this industry, so I've been following it from the start. I've run test cells and written software to analyze the results from the emissions cycles that the government uses to validate the emissions compliance. I have worked around and for a very large diesel engine manufacturer who I am convinced does not cheat on this test. You'll understand why, below.

I recently leveled-up my career, and I now work with the person who originally setup such testing at this manufacturer, and one of the two people who literally wrote the spec, which is one of the most thorough technical documents I've ever laid eyes on. These are 2 of the highest-caliber engineers I have ever met in my 25-year professional career, both in terms of intelligence and capability, and in terms of integrity and trustworthiness.

This quote from the article pisses me off: "What I understand now is that the people we entrusted with the power to protect us essentially decided not to bother. Instead, they have allowed carmakers to spew whatever they want into our air." Really?! The government commissioned the spec. The government mandated that engine makers make their engines comply, and validate this compliance with internal testing. The government then paid independent testers to validate the manufacturer's results.

Excuse me, but what more did the author expect the government to do? The regulators entrusted this process to expert engineers, and expert testers. Did the author expect people who could invent the spec and create a test cell to do the validation to go to work for the EPA directly, and do the paperwork, instead of the engineering? Did they expect them to escrow the code, and validate that there was no cheating? Possible, but, again, you're asking a very specific skillset to give up DOING, and instead REGULATING, and that doesn't usually work.

The fault of this scandal lies -- of course -- with the manufacturers, but the fault also lies with the legislators. To control diesel engine emissions within the spec requires an array of very expensive after-treatment components. That can work in the class-8 heavy trucking industry, but you can't even fit it into a passenger car, let alone make it affordable at gasoline car prices. To think that cars could use diesel engines, be cost-competitive with gasoline-fueled alternatives, AND pass the ridiculously-low emissions standards that lawmakers have arbitrarily decreed was simply wishful thinking.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by ummonk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @01:05AM (#19469146)
>To think that cars could use diesel engines, be cost-competitive with gasoline-fueled alternatives, AND pass the ridiculously-low emissions standards that lawmakers have arbitrarily decreed was simply wishful thinking.

The emissions standards are perfectly sensible for maintaining good air quality. It definitely looks like it is wishful thinking for diesel engines to meet those standards and be cost-competitive with gasoline-fueled alternatives, but there is nothing wrong with that. Gasoline engines may simply be the more suitable technology for passenger cars.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by Reason077 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @02:28AM (#19469310)
> It definitely looks like it is wishful thinking for diesel engines to meet those standards and be cost-competitive with gasoline-fueled alternatives

The technology that would have brought "Dieselgate" diesels into compliance with EU emissions rules was said to cost manufacturers something on the order of US$100 per vehicle: Selective catalytic reduction (SCR) with a refillable AdBlue (urea) tank.

However, prior to Dieselgate there is alleged to have been collusion between the major German automakers and a secret agreement not to install it on small vehicles.

This collusion, rather than the emissions cheating itself, is the focus of ongoing criminal investigations in Germany. (Cheating on emissions tests itself was not actually illegal in Europe, because the legislation was created with loopholes).

As of 2019, AdBlue is becoming common on new small diesel vehicles in Europe.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by alkonaut on Saturday March 23, 2019 @02:46AM (#19469349)
The Euro6 standard was launched back in 2014, following the Euro4- and 5 standards that most of the diesel-gate cars adhered to. Most cars manufactured from around 2016/17 are Euro6, and as far as I’m aware Urea tanks are in use on most or all.

I honestly don’t understand why it would have been an issue to have it before. My diesel tank is 65L and it takes me over 1000km. Even if they had made a 10L Urea tank and shrunk the gas tank to make room for it, the range is still more than enough. Filling it takes 5 minutes once every 1-2 years and costs about the same as windshield wiper fluid. Can’t see why that would make the car unappealing either.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by junga on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:31AM (#19469759)
> Filling it takes 5 minutes once every 1-2 years

Isn‘t this a part of the problem? The urea tanks are way too small and need refilling way too seldom which means a too low urea usage? Volkswagen wanted urea to be refilled by your service station and not by the customers themselves because they might have found this inconvenient.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by makomk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:37AM (#19470037)
The problem wasn't just that it was an inconvenience. Under the EPA rules of the time, urea refills were considered critical emission-related maintenance. Initially, this meant that they had to last 100,000-150,000 miles unless the EPA gave a waiver allowing more frequent servicing intervals.[1] This wasn't physically feasible. A couple of years into Dieselgate, they decided they'd allow DEF refills at the oil change interval, which still required much larger tanks than the European models (typically replacing the spare tyre) or cheating.[2] It wasn't until mid-2014 that they decided users could be allowed to refill their own urea tanks and lowered the minimum DEF refill interval for cars to a slightly more reasonable 4,000 miles.[3]

[1] https://iaspub.epa.gov/otaqpub/display_file.jsp?docid=16677&...

[2] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2009-11-09/pdf/E9-269...

[3] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2014-08-08/pdf/2014-1...

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by alkonaut on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:09AM (#19469974)
My last car was a diesel-gate car (09 Audi) which didn’t have a Urea tank at all.

I know VW managers first thought Urea was an inconvenience to have at all, then an inconvenience for owners to refill so should last a service interval. My new car has a Urea tank and isn’t a diesel-gate car. It need to refill maybe 1 time before the service intervals. I can’t see why it would be considered inconvenient - it’s easier to refill than windshield wiper fluid (that you need to pop the hood for!). So if it would have come at a price of 20L diesel capacity space, and require refills every month, I still wouldn’t have found it inconvenient.

I don’t know how they determine how much AdBlue to consume now, but I’m guessing since they now manage to comply with regulation they just use as little as possible? If they can further limit emissions by using more, then there’s some headroom for improving too.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by Reason077 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:49AM (#19469926)
Exactly. If it's only being filled with (eg) 8L every 1-2 years, then it's not being used much and is probably not very effective at reducing NOx emissions.

Depending on the engine, driving style, etc, it should really be using something on the order of 20-60 litres of AdBlue per 1000 litres of diesel.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by makomk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:12AM (#19469982)
There were some pretty big licensing hurdles to getting the EPA to accept urea tanks as part of an emissions control system: https://iaspub.epa.gov/otaqpub/display_file.jsp?docid=16677&...

Also, note that the 2007 Tier 2 NOx emissions standards mentioned in that document are pretty much as strict as the 2014 Euro6 standard, at least for manufacturers which mainly produce diesel cars. The EU emissions standards were much weaker back then, giving manufacturers more time to develop tech to meet the stricter standard.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by topspin on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:37AM (#19469777)
"Excuse me, but what more did the author expect the government to do?"

It is not some outrageous expectation that the $8,000,000,000+/year, 14,000+ employee EPA and/or DOT independently verify the real world emissions performance of passenger cars and other vehicles. The cars were so grossly out of compliance that anyone with a ordinary field emissions testing machine could have caught it.

If, as is very likely the case, the regulators had no technical resources among their hordes of lawyers they could have asked any number of publicly funded universities to perform the actual investigation and go beyond the agreed upon and easily fooled test regime. The discovery was actually made by US academics with very limited financing.

This institutional pencil whipping is SOP at EPA. GOA had a gasoline powered alarm clock (among other improbable devices) Energy Star certified as part of an investigation in 2010. Energy Star certifications are literally pencil whipped through an automated system with no human review.

When the EPA found itself answering for their part in the emissions scandal in public hearings there was no defense. They didn't even try to cite limited budgets[1] -- the go-to excuse every time some regulator comes up short -- as a cause. They just failed.

That's difficult to accept for some, and so all manner of rationalizations are employed to dilute that simple truth. But I'm not among them.

[1] https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4787386/blaming-budget

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by TheRealDunkirk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:46AM (#19470051)
I still shake my head at this. If you wrote laws that said manufacturers of a particular thing had to do X, and expected them to adhere to it internally, and then paid expert testing facilities to validate those results, why would you EXPECT that you would have to do additional testing to validate the validation?

And further more, why would you think that merely testing the test would lead to a different result? You can say that the Euro V is "not representative" (as someone else did in this thread) of normal driving, but the FTP test's torque and RPM curves were lifted from real-world driving through hilly areas. It most definitely is representative. I don't know about the Euro V.

So I don't get it. In this scenario, what people are asking the EPA to have done was load up vehicles with mobile emissions equipment (which is a very difficult thing to do, by the way), and validate that the TEST ITSELF correlated with real-world driving. Granted, this is an interesting exercise, but one that I would expect the EPA to - again - pay someone else to do.

Given the engineering that went into the spec on the US side, I wouldn't expect that this was something they should have needed to do. You can say that they were the regulatory body in charge of this, and therefore should be responsible for catching cheaters, but I don't see how a reasonable person can find that the EPA was intentionally negligent in this matter.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by stefan_ on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:08AM (#19470743)
Nobody charged the EPA with ensuring adherence to some made up test cycle, but to the emission limits. If the test cycle is your approximation of real world behavior, it is highly negligent to never confirm that real world results actually match the approximation! This is science 101.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by TheRealDunkirk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:55PM (#19472553)
I’m specifically arguing that the FTP cycle result IS, in fact, a real world result. So to me, claiming that the EPA needed to do their own verification would be silly. The only reason to do this would be to catch cheaters.

I know I’m naive, and very trusting. I would never have thought a company to have the utter stones to completely fake the results as VW did. If you’ve looked at the depths of their algorithms to do it, you see the effort that went into it. I just would never expect such behavior from one of the largest auto makers. It’s so far beyond the pale to my expectations that I can’t blame the EPA for not catching it.

YMMV.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by ip26 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:41PM (#19471156)
I'm not a test engineer but work closely with them- two of their core ongoing job functions are monitoring real world performance to find test escapes, and adapting the tests to more closely drive real world performance.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by topspin on Saturday March 23, 2019 @04:47PM (#19472285)
"what people are asking the EPA to have done was load up vehicles with mobile emissions equipment (which is a very difficult thing to do, by the way):

No, that's incorrect in several ways.

There was/is no need for mobile equipment; simply deviating from the test regime on a stationary emissions test machine was sufficient to expose the defeat device. The defeat device worked by detecting the test conditions and defeating that detection is easy. Turning the steering wheel while testing, for example, will inhibit the VW defeat device. Simply running the test long enough (at least 26 minutes) would have exposed it with some common models.

Also, mobile testing is not 'a very difficult thing to do.'

For a time in the early 90's I was certified to perform emissions tests. At that time the actual machine fit on a wheeled cart; two men could hoist it into the rear of light pickup in a few minutes. I actually did that when we needed to move one to another site to replace another that had failed. That wasn't strictly legal (the units were certified for operation at a designated site) but the station owner didn't give a damn; he needed a temporary replacement unit and was not above fudging the paper work.

So nigh on 30 years ago any given wrench monkey with a power inverter could have operated an exhaust analyzer from a moving vehicle. Today the units are even smaller; now we have HAND HELD exhaust analyzers[1].

We've also had remote sensing emission testing equipment available for at least 10 years now. Output is detected as the vehicle drives by the unit; no need for anything on board at all.

Face it. There is simply no excuse. The regulator failed utterly. The regulator publicly admitted their failure without qualification. Your faith is misplaced and your rationalizations do not work. This is, assuming intellectual honesty, the point where you adapt your worldview, because the one you have is simply wrong.

[1] https://thecarlsoncompany.com/products/infrared-industries-h...

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by TheRealDunkirk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:50PM (#19472535)
Didn’t know about those devices. Doubt they qualify for certification compliance, but I guess it would get you on paper.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by specialist on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:18AM (#19470134)
We need better models of governance.

One party arrangements (self-policing) ain't working.

Two party arrangements (regulation) is hit or miss.

Maybe add a third chair to each negotiation. Just like the US Constitution has three branches of government. What would that look like?

Maybe incentivize competitors to narc on each other. What would it have taken for Mazda (for example) to blow the whistle?

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by elizabethholmez on Sunday March 24, 2019 @12:00AM (#19474206)
1. massively weaken European defamation laws

2. make NDAs and noncompetes illegal

3. remove all taxes on journalists and jouranlistic organizations

4. force companies to put whistleblowers on their boards of directors.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by stefan_ on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:54AM (#19469935)
Why do you think escalating emissions standards exist? The entire purpose is to gradually retire whole technologies!

It is essentially deprecation. The ultimate goal is always reduce to zero, you will find very few emissions in our continuous world that are somehow safe at arbitrary cutoff X but unsafe above.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by ip26 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:03AM (#19469006)
I guess it depends a little on whether you feel like the spec writer or testers should have anticipated cheating, and attempted to detect it or not. If the job of a tester includes catching cheaters, or if a good spec should be very hard to cheat, I'm not sure missing that falls at the feet of the legislators.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by wil421 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:43AM (#19469091)
How can VW create an engine, cheat, and sell it to Chrysler? Then Chrysler has to put a urea tank to meet emissions. How did some brilliant engineer writing the spec or the third parties not notice?
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by TheRealDunkirk on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:50AM (#19470060)
An SCR (and EGR, and DOC, et. al.) is a "given" in this equation. There's no hope of passing emissions without it. Even on gas engines, you still need a catalytic converter to pass.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by wil421 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:00AM (#19470271)
My point is VW sold a TDI engine in the US. The same engine was sold to Jeep and used in the Grand Cherokee but with extra emission controls like urea. If I worked at Jeep or one of the 3rd party testers I would’ve made a lot of noise about VWs lack of a urea tank.