News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Phone Numbers Stink as Identity Proof by giobox on Friday March 22, 2019 @03:44PM (#19466169)
This doesn’t solve the original problem though, this is just a potential mitigation strategy for when/if it goes bad (e.g. the cell number is hijacked).

It’s personally annoying to me how many 2 factor equipped sites force the use of SMS as the second factor. I imagine the conversation with the PO/PM for the feature must frequently include discussion of fears that allowing customers to opt out of SMS 2FA and use their own code generation tools is risky; you are relying on customer not screwing up to keep them as a paying customer.

They lose their personal Authenticator and recovery keys, it can be really awkward to fix. SMS could be argued to be superficially more attractive in this regard, given a cell number can be reissued unlike the permanently lost authenticator device/app. Of course the security of SMS 2FA is terrible etc, but I can understand some of the fear of the alternatives if you need to keep customers happy and able to actually use your service.

There are no comments on this comment yet.