But then how do you order them to know which one came first. What if two transactions come at the same time? Let's split them into chunks that will be added every X minutes.
And how do you make sure that the chunks aren't messed with/reordered/whatever? Let's make each chunk reference the previous one through a hash.
Oh wait.
You don't need the batching mechanism quite so badly and ACID databases have a pretty good track record at establishing a trustworthy ordering of events.
With both a private blockchain and a signed transaction log you have to rely on the tx log/blockchain being published so that third parties can verify that all updates are consistent.
Maybe it is?
I think people don't want other people to know their balance, but remember, Uncle Sam prints the money, so he gets what he wants.
I do think we'll move to a cashless society exactly for this reason. It might be blockchain based. But I'm skeptical it will be a utopian move where we can all inspect the chain and verify no one is cheating.
I am pretty sure in the future the IRS will have the ability to know the details of every USD denominated transaction. Even still, I'm skeptical this will do much to stop tax evasion and fraud.
Whether or not such a system exists is mostly orthogonal to the question of whether or not cash exists. Cash can be eliminated whether or not it's replaced with a reasonable alternative, and the reasonable alternative can exist without eliminating cash. The nightmare scenario is the elimination of cash, and replacing it with an insecure, inefficient system run by a bunch of rent-seeking oligarchs. (Sadly, that outcome also seems to be the most likely in the U.S.)
There is one sense in which a private cryptocurrency could be tremendously useful: a currency with a ledger maintained by a TTP but where transactions were authorized with proper digital signatures would be both more efficient and much more resistant to fraud than any other current (no pun intended) method of transferring money.